Progressão podcast

#218 The chessboard and the river: positionism vs relationism (Space and time III)

2026-11-17
0:00
21:30
Spola tillbaka 15 sekunder
Spola framåt 15 sekunder

Duration. Henri Bergson’s word for the time we actually live inside, as opposed to the time on the clock. A continuous, qualitative flow in which the past of the moment is still present and the future is already arriving. You can only be inside it, more or less deeply.

David Bohm said that the way we argue is wrong. We call it thinking, but most of the time we are defending positions we arrived with. Real thinking, he said, is dialogue — meaning flowing through, not positions competing. A passing move, when it works, is a dialogue.

Both of them were pointing at the same distinction, which is related to current football discourse.

The chessboard. Pieces on squares. Structure lives in positions. A snapshot of the right frame is the right game. The whole positional play tradition — Cruyff, Lillo, Guardiola — rests here.

The river. Water in continuous mutual response. Structure emerges from relationships in flow, never static, never fully captured in a frame. The relational tradition — Diniz, Fluminense, the Brazilian ideal — rests here.

This is more than a tactical argument. It is an argument about what the pitch is. And the answer has consequences for how we coach, how we design sessions, and how we think about football.

🌍 More at progressao.fi
 📷 Instagram @progressaofi
 👥 LinkedIn @Project Progressão

Fler avsnitt från "Progressão"