
My guest on the show today is Georgetown University historian and former editor of Dissent Michael Kazin. His books include American Dreamers: How the Left Changed a Nation, The Populist Persuasion, and A Godly Hero: The Life of William Jennings Bryan. Our text for our conversation is his recent essay in the Dissent, “The Left Needs Ideas.”
I want to give you a paragraph from early in his essay to pre-empt, or reframe, a criticism of this conversation that I can imagine coming my way, which is that it’s a weird one to have just a week or two after the massive blue wave in the elections, a wave that included a number of really high profile unapologetically left wing candidates.
Kazin, no more than any of the rest of us, predicted such a staggeringly huge victory, but it’s evident in this passage that he did anticipate the possibility of a victory:
For many years now, a majority of Americans have told pollsters the country is on the wrong track. That sentiment speaks to a profound malaise and a sense of gradual decline that cannot be satisfactorily addressed, much less solved, by clever campaign strategies and appealing policy ideas alone. … We need big ideas that go beyond the populist bashing of billionaires, justified as it is, and programs that would produce an egalitarian green economy. We need to express a worldview that appeals to the millions of working-class Americans who feel they get no relief from politics, whether practiced by intellectuals, activists, or officeholders.
Kazin draws a distinction in the piece between a post-liberal right, which he locates in intellectuals like Patrick Deneen and Adrien Vermuele, that seems fairly dumb, policy-wise, but has a coherent vision of the society it wants to bring into being. Whereas on the left you have a lot of compelling criticisms – of Trump, of billionaires, of big tech, big pharma, big finance – and some excellent policy proposals (Green New Deal, anti-trust reform, Medicare for all) but not much of a vision of a more beautiful society in which people would want to live.
His historical template for what such a left-wing, or left-inspired, vision would look like is the New Deal, and to a lesser extent the earlier, more optimistic years of the New Left.
Our conversation ranges back and forth between the history of the American left in the 20th and 21st centuries, on the one hand, and the complexities of the present. Is the DSA, which he recently rejoined after a long absence from its membership rolls, capable of meaningfully answering his call, articulating a vision, or building a movement around a vision, that is compelling to more than just the left? Or is it heir to illiberal and anti-American strands of the left, unable to inspire average people to dream of a better America because it doesn’t really believe in the possibility of an actually admirable America but only a modestly less awfulk America?
All of which is to say that this is, IMHO, actually a really good conversation to have right now, flush from last week’s victory. We won power, and that we includes some actual lefties. If the role of the left in American politics is, as Kazin says, “to stretch the boundaries of the possible,” then toward what should it be stretching?
How should it respond to the “profound malaise” that Kazin believes Americans have been feeling for a long time. Affordability is not an answer to malaise. Medicare for all is not an answer to malaise. Humiliating Elon Musk would probably be a brief reprieve from malaise, but only brief. How can the left stretch the boundaries of the possible that feeds into a larger vision of the good life, of a good and vital America, that can compel people who aren’t currently in the ranks of the Democratic party?
We don’t arrive at any brilliant answers, but it’s a fascinating conversation.
Eminent Americans is produced in collaboration with the John C Danforth Center on Relgiion and Politics at Washington University in St. Louis, and with its publication, Arc. Check out what’s going on at Arc at their website, arcmag.org.
Peace
Last week I made my network TV debut, appearing as a guest on the Tamron Hall show to discuss “money, masculinity, and marriage.” It was a lot of fun. Still processing, and may have more say to later. -Dan
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit danieloppenheimer.substack.com/subscribe
Fler avsnitt från "Eminent Americans"



Missa inte ett avsnitt av “Eminent Americans” och prenumerera på det i GetPodcast-appen.








