
“I own 40% of you, and I’m winding you up!”
____
The Ps sued to wind up a Co pursuant to s461(1)(k), the “just and equitable” basis. The Co opposed: [1], [4]
The Ps held 40% of the Co’s shares, an SPV incorp’d for residential development: [1], [2], [157]
The remaining 60% to 2 entities whose controlling minds were also Dirs of the Co: [7] – [11]
The Ps referred to: apparent insolvency of the Co, a breakdown of relationships, and “exorbitant” mgmt fees “gouged” by an entity related to 2 of the Co’s Dirs: [3], [149] – [151]
In 2021 the Ps and the Co had entered into an arrangement where the Ps loaned ~$5m for buying the property, to be repaid from profits following development: [12]
In December 2021, the Co bought the property for ~$10m; funded in part by the Ps’ loan: [13] – [15]
The Dirs of the Co incorp’d OtherCo to provided management services to the Co; $30K per month. The Ps were not told of this: [16] – [20]
From 2022, the Co undertook various steps (including running NSWLEC proceedings) to obtain relevant DAs: [21] – [28]
Rent was collected on the Co’s property from 2022. It was not paid to the Co but was paid to OtherCo: [29] – [31]
The Ps initially sued seeking repayment of the $5m. They lost: [32] – [34]
The Ps took the view the development was “unviable”; likely unprofitable. The Court accepted this: [43], [95]
The Ps’ experts’ figures suggest the development would be worth $22m, for a cost of $35m; a loss of ~$13m: [45] – [88]
The Court accepted there was no possibility of the Co obtaining external finance: [110], [158]
Nor was it likely finance could be obtained from a related party: [117]
The Court noted insolvency may be relevant to a just and equitable wind up application: [118]
After extended considering of the relevant tests for insolvency, and with the assistance of expert evidence, the Court accepted the Co was likely cash flow and balance sheet insolvent: [148]
The Court lacked confidence in the conduct of the Co’s affairs, such that it was just and equitable that it be wound up: [164]
Where the Co was not run as a quasi-partnership, the fact that there was a breakdown in the relationship of trust and confidence between the parties was not sufficient to obtain a winding up order: [169] – [176]
The Court found there were no alternative s 467(4) remedies: [177] – [195]
The Court ordered that the Co be wound up and that the Ps’ legal costs would be costs in the winding up: [199]
___
Please look out for James d'Apice, Coffee and a Case Note, and Gravamen on your favourite platform.
www.gravamen.com.au
#auslaw #coffeeandacasenote #gravamen
Fler avsnitt från "Coffee and a Case Note"



Missa inte ett avsnitt av “Coffee and a Case Note” och prenumerera på det i GetPodcast-appen.








