Is It That Good, or Are You Just A Boy?

This week, Katie and Jasmine talk about American Psycho (2000). They discuss men's glorification of Patrick Bateman, why it's interesting that this film was written/directed by women, and how the film's relevance continues to increase over time. FOLLOW US ON INSTAGRAM <3@areyoujustaboypod | @jasminejbinder | @kathryn.kirkFOLLOW US ON TIKTOK <3@areyoujustaboypod | @jasminejbinder | @reginaisafuglycowVIDEO VERSIONS LIVE ON OUR YOUTUBE <3https://www.youtube.com/@IsItThatGoodorAreYouJustABoy

This week, Katie and Jasmine talk about Other Mommy (2026). They question why audience's dislike the movie so much, how the film explores the complexities of motherhood and parenting, and the way the film discusses childhood trauma.FOLLOW US ON INSTAGRAM <3@areyoujustaboypod | @jasminejbinder | @kathryn.kirkFOLLOW US ON TIKTOK <3@areyoujustaboypod | @jasminejbinder | @reginaisafuglycowVIDEO VERSIONS LIVE ON OUR YOUTUBE <3https://www.youtube.com/@IsItThatGoodorAreYouJustABoy

This week, Katie and Jasmine do another edition of their Criterion Closet Cosplay series where they pick the movies for each other! Katie discusses her thoughts on Twin Peaks: Fire Walk With Me (1992), Jasmine discusses her thoughts on From Dusk Till Dawn (1996), and they both compare the themes of violence against women in both films.FOLLOW US ON INSTAGRAM @areyoujustaboypod | @jasminejbinder | @kathryn.kirkFOLLOW US ON TIKTOK@areyoujustaboypod | @jasminejbinder | @reginaisafuglycow VIDEO VERSIONS LIVE ON OUR YOUTUBE <3https://www.youtube.com/@IsItThatGoodorAreYouJustABoy

This week, Katie and Jasmine talk about Teenage Sex and Death at Camp Miasma (2026). They discuss their enjoyment of how the film handles women's sexuality, the films Camp Miasma is reminiscent of, and whether or not Billy and Kris' romantic relationship is earned. FOLLOW US ON INSTAGRAM <3@areyoujustaboypod | @jasminejbinder | @kathryn.kirkFOLLOW US ON TIKTOK <3@areyoujustaboypod | @jasminejbinder | @reginaisafuglycowVIDEO VERSIONS LIVE ON OUR YOUTUBE <3https://www.youtube.com/@IsItThatGoodorAreYouJustABoy

This week, Katie and Jasmine talk about Practical Magic (1998) ahead of the release of its sequel. They discuss their own personal relationships with the film, how different the film is from the book, and why people yearn for the witchy cult classics of the 90s. FOLLOW US ON INSTAGRAM <3@areyoujustaboypod | @jasminejbinder | @kathryn.kirkFOLLOW US ON TIKTOK <3@areyoujustaboypod | @jasminejbinder | @reginaisafuglycowVIDEO VERSIONS LIVE ON OUR YOUTUBE <3https://www.youtube.com/@IsItThatGoodorAreYouJustABoy

This week, Katie and Jasmine talk about the queer, cult classic Bound (1996). They talk about how realistically the film depicts a queer relationship, the Wachowski sisters' unique directing style, and how different the mob storyline would've been written if the film was written by men.FOLLOW US ON INSTAGRAM <3@areyoujustaboypod | @jasminejbinder | kathryn.kirkFOLLOW US ON TIKTOK <3@areyoujustaboypod | @jasminejbinder | @reginaisafuglycow VIDEO VERSIONS LIVE ON OUR YOUTUBE <3https://www.youtube.com/@IsItThatGoodorAreYouJustABoy

This week, Katie and Jasmine do their first Criterion Closet Cosplay episode where they pick the movies for each other! Katie discusses the complex mother/daughter relationship in Postcards From The Edge (1990), Jasmine discusses her problems with Gone With The Wind (1939), and they both compare the surprising similarities between the two films. FOLLOW US ON INSTAGRAM @areyoujustaboypod | @jasminejbinder | @kathryn.kirkFOLLOW US ON TIKTOK@areyoujustaboypod | @jasminejbinder | @reginaisafuglycow VIDEO VERSIONS LIVE ON OUR YOUTUBE https://www.youtube.com/@IsItThatGoodorAreYouJustABoy

This week, Katie and Jasmine break the first rules of Fight Club (1999). They dissect the inherent queerness of the film, discuss how the satire is used as a social commentary, and explore what makes the plot twist so effective. FOLLOW US ON INSTAGRAM @areyoujustaboypod | @jasminejbinder | kathryn.kirkFOLLOW US ON TIKTOK@areyoujustaboypod | @jasminejbinder | @reginaisafuglycow VIDEO VERSIONS LIVE ON OUR YOUTUBE https://www.youtube.com/@IsItThatGoodorAreYouJustABoy

This week, Katie and Jasmine dissect Christopher Nolan's latest blockbuster, The Odyssey (2026). They explore what makes the film different from the book, whether or not the women of the film are merely symbols, and if Nolan sacrifices dialogue and characterization for the sake of epic filmmaking.FOLLOW US ON INSTAGRAM @areyoujustaboypod | @jasminejbinder | @kathryn.kirkFOLLOW US ON TIKTOK @areyoujustaboypod | @jasminejbinder | @reginaisafuglycowVIDEO VERSIONS LIVE ON OUR YOUTUBE https://www.youtube.com/@IsItThatGoodorAreYouJustABoy

This week, Katie and Jasmine introduce themselves to the world of podcasting and dissect the horror film Scream (1996). They explore the history of creating the film, the things that make Scream extra scary for young women, and Billy and Stu's seemingly queer bond. FOLLOW US ON INSTAGRAM @areyoujustaboypod | @jasminejbinder | @kathryn.kirkFOLLOW US ON TIKTOK @areyoujustaboypod | @jasminejbinder | @reginaisafuglycowVIDEO VERSIONS LIVE ON OUR YOUTUBE https://www.youtube.com/@IsItThatGoodorAreYouJustABoy