
Garbage disposals in rentals are the only appliance I can think of that costs a hundred dollars and can quietly turn into a several thousand dollar problem. And nobody requires you to provide one at all.
Kevin opens with the distinction that decides how fast you have to answer that late night text. A disposal is an amenity, not a habitability item. Except there is one specific moment when it stops being either of those, and it is not the moment most landlords assume.
Then he makes the case for skipping them entirely. Five reasons, and only one of them is really about money. Two apply to buildings and systems most of us never connect to that little motor under the sink.
From there I walk through what we actually do, because we have disposals in every one of our units and no plans to change that. It has almost nothing to do with the brand we buy. It is about what a tenant gets in the first twenty minutes they are in that unit, plus one small item taped where they cannot miss it. Since we put this in place, our replacement rate dropped seventy five percent. I show you the math.
Plus what a replacement really costs us, the trick that saves fifty dollars every single time, the shop towel trick our contractor uses to catch a leak months before it soaks a cabinet, and the one thing to tell every tenant before they ever reach for a bottle under the sink.
Hit play. You will know by the end whether a disposal belongs in your unit or not.
What You'll Learn in This Episode
- Why a disposal is an amenity, and the exact moment it stops being one
- Five reasons some landlords refuse to install them
- The two building types where a disposal is a genuinely bad idea
- What your tenant class has to do with the decision
- The small item we tape inside every sink cabinet door
- How we cut our replacement rate by seventy five percent
- What a replacement costs us, and the fifty dollar trick
- The horsepower rule for anything going in a rental
- The one product to tell tenants never to use
- Our contractor's shop towel trick for catching a slow leak early
- Why a disposal will not raise your rent, but still earns its spot
Episodes & Resources Mentioned
Episode 59: Determining Wear and Tear Vs. Damage to Your Rental Property — named on air, Kevin asks listeners to check it out
Episode 137: Emergency Maintenance vs Routine Repairs — what is urgent and what can wait
Episode 96: Tips From Our Contractor — everything Jim has taught us
Kevin's Disposal Reset & Jam Video — the video we send tenants
InSinkErator Badger 5 — the unit we buy, Amazon affiliate link
Disposal Hex Wrench — the backup wrench Kevin mentions we keep on hand for insinkerator disposals
DoorLoop: Landlord software for larger portfolios
TurboTenant: Landlord software for newer landlords
Avail: Free Landlord Software
EZ Landlord Forms: State-specific lease and notice forms
Connect with Us:
🌎 Visit our website
📧 Subscribe to our newsletter.
👆 FREE Landlord Forms and Doc’s
🤳Text Us: 650-489-4447
📩Email us at: [email protected], [email protected]
More episodes from "Your Landlord Resource Podcast"



Don't miss an episode of “Your Landlord Resource Podcast” and subscribe to it in the GetPodcast app.








