Valley Morning Briefing podcast

Nov 9: Nvidia Opens Huang Spy Probe; AI Proves Quantum Conjecture

0:00
13:27
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds

Nvidia's board is investigating whether Chinese intelligence targeted CEO Jensen Huang, and a startup says an unreleased Claude model proved the Aaronson-Ambainis conjecture in quantum computing. Also: buyers now discuss an Anthropic IPO valuation of about 1.2 to 1.3 trillion dollars, plus quick hits on Anthropic's gas generators, DeepMind's RSA findings, DeepSeek Harness, Apple's Siri plans and October's white-collar jobs.

Nvidia board investigates China spy case around Jensen Huang
Nvidia's board opened an independent investigation after reports that China's Ministry of State Security recruited Megaspeed executive Alice Huang to gather information on Jensen Huang, who admitted an affair with her, while Trump backed him and lawmakers from both parties want answers.
Nvidia · CNBC · Bloomberg (via Yahoo Finance)

AI system proves the Aaronson-Ambainis conjecture
Physical Superintelligence says its system, running a non-public Anthropic model, produced a Lean-verified proof of the conjecture, which limits quantum speedups on random inputs, and Scott Aaronson says he believes it is correct.
Physical Superintelligence (GitHub) · Shtetl-Optimized

Anthropic pays 3.4 billion dollars for gas generators
The FT reports that Anthropic took over OnePWR's Caterpillar order for 1.7 gigawatts of gas-fired generators for about 3.4 billion dollars.
The Next Web · Anthropic S-1/A (SEC)

DeepMind agents find new weaknesses in 1024-bit RSA
Google DeepMind says AI agents found a forgery method about 1,600 times better in theory and a batch attack on paper, while 2048-bit keys are not affected.
Interesting Engineering

Tencent's Yao Shunyu warns about AI biology risks
Tencent's chief AI scientist said AI will soon make it actually possible to do harm in biology, but still argued for a mix of open and closed models as Tencent prepares to release Hy4's weights.
South China Morning Post

DeepSeek Harness reaches 1.54 million daily users
DeepSeek says Harness users on its official API grew from 271,000 to 1.54 million a day and consume about 92 trillion tokens daily.
Yicai Global · Google

Apple's Ternus pushes Federighi to speed up software
Mark Gurman reports that John Ternus told Craig Federighi to go beyond Siri fixes, and he believes Siri could work more like an agent as early as next year.
MacRumors

John Langford leaves Microsoft as AI Frontiers ends
Langford says his roughly 50-person lab ended after it moved into Microsoft AI, whose leaders he says favor scaling and aggressively not research.
hunch.net

Claude Code settings files leaked secrets on GitHub
Apiiro found 1,122 public GitHub files in which Claude Code had saved real passwords and API keys, and Boris Cherny says Anthropic is looking at fixes.
iTnews · Hacker News

White-collar jobs jump in October
Professional and business services added 70,000 jobs in October, but economists disagree on whether it is a real reversal or a bump from federal and election spending.
Bureau of Labor Statistics · Marketplace · Lee Enterprises

Anthropic IPO valuation falls toward 1.2 trillion dollars
Bloomberg reports that some buyers discuss 1.2 to 1.3 trillion dollars, as low as 1.1 trillion, and investors disagree on whether a lower price is a warning sign or a healthy reset.
Investing.com · Axios · Yahoo Finance · Financial News (fnnews)

The most important news from Silicon Valley and AI. 15 minutes, every weekday morning.

Transcript

Good morning. It's Monday, November 9, and this is the Valley Morning Briefing. Today: Nvidia's board is investigating whether Chinese intelligence targeted Jensen Huang. An AI startup says an unreleased Claude model proved the Aaronson-Ambainis conjecture. And some buyers now put Anthropic's IPO valuation near 1.2 trillion dollars. Let's start with Nvidia.

Nvidia's board said on Sunday that it has opened an independent investigation into whether its chief executive, Jensen Huang, was the target of a Chinese intelligence operation. A committee of independent directors will oversee it, with help from outside lawyers. The board says it has no reason to believe that national security or Nvidia secrets were compromised, and that it has confidence in Huang. It gave no timeline and did not name the law firm. The board acted after the New York Times and the Financial Times wrote about the case. According to those reports, US intelligence concluded that China's Ministry of State Security recruited a woman named Alice Huang to gather information on Jensen Huang. The two are not related. She is an executive at Megaspeed, a cloud company in Singapore that buys Nvidia chips. The US has suspected Megaspeed of helping restricted Chinese companies get those chips. The Times also reports that her task may have included pushing for Nvidia's advanced chips to be sold in China, against current rules. On Sunday, Jensen Huang admitted in an email to staff that he had an affair with her. He wrote that his colleagues, board and shareholders deserve better from him, and that he is fully committed to Nvidia. The company says he will keep leading it without interruption. Earlier, he had described his contacts with her as normal business with a customer. Nvidia was worth nearly 4.5 trillion dollars on Friday. Huang has also been one of the main advocates in Washington for selling more AI chips to China. The Times reported on Sunday that Secretary of State Marco Rubio oversaw a secret memo last spring that warned officials about the relationship. Rubio told reporters he could not comment. President Trump backed Huang. He said: "I just know he's a fine person, but you never know what is going on." He also said Huang should stay on as CEO, and that he would take him on his Asia trip later this month. Asked whether he wished he had acted on the intelligence, Trump said no. In Congress, the pressure comes from both parties. Three Republican House committee chairs, among them John Moolenaar of the House China committee, have asked Huang to a closed-door briefing. Democratic Senator Chris Coons wrote on X that Congress will investigate and get answers. He is expected to lead the Senate Foreign Relations Committee once Democrats take control of the Senate in January. Representative Seth Magaziner, also a Democrat, wants Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick to testify alongside Huang. A separate Times report found that the administration cleared a Chinese firm, New Matrix, to assemble Nvidia chips in Beijing, with little sign of real operations at its address. The Republican Senator John Cornyn called that report "outrageous." So far, no lawmaker has asked Huang to step aside. Nvidia reports quarterly earnings on November 17. The House Republicans want their briefing the next day.

A startup called Physical Superintelligence says its AI system has proved the Aaronson-Ambainis conjecture, one of the central open problems in quantum computing theory. Scott Aaronson, who posed the conjecture with Andris Ambainis in 2009, says he believes the proof is correct. The result sets a limit on quantum speedups. For yes-or-no questions on random inputs, a classical computer can simulate any quantum algorithm and needs only polynomially more reads of the input. So on such inputs, quantum computers cannot get an exponential advantage in this measure. Aaronson says this answers a question that has been open since 1998. The company, known as PSI, is based in Cambridge, Massachusetts, and launched in September. Its research system ran many copies of a non-public Anthropic model. Some copies searched the literature and tested arguments, and others coordinated the work. The system had a complete proof on the third day of the run, and later improved the bound twice. The proof is written in Lean, and two independent Lean checkers verified it. Humans did a lot of the setup. The PSI researcher David Turturean built the system, chose the problem and edited the paper, and he takes responsibility for it. The proof follows a 2023 plan by Shachar Lovett and Jiapeng Zhang and fills the gap they left open. The paper has not been peer reviewed. PSI itself says a human still has to confirm that the Lean statement matches the original conjecture. Neither PSI nor Anthropic has said which model it was. Four researchers from MIT and Stanford, who proved a special case in August, have read the full proof. In a statement published by PSI, they call it "a huge result." Aaronson writes that the proof has zero effect on Shor's factoring algorithm and on simulating physics and chemistry. Pedro Domingos of the University of Washington posted that the dream of quantum supremacy is dead, and Aaronson calls him intellectually dishonest for it. Guido Appenzeller of a16z wrote on X that the result partly explains why few useful quantum applications have been found. Sophia Gold, formerly of the Ethereum Foundation, wrote that experts expected this answer anyway. Aaronson also says he is tired of what he calls the never-ending buffet of solutions to long-standing open problems. He says he is satisfied, but also disappointed that humans did not solve this one before the robots. He thinks it is very likely that they would have, with more years of work, and he later stressed that he did not say how many. A researcher who spent much of their PhD on the problem disagreed in the comments on his blog. They wrote that a human solver would have had to know one of two older results, and that they knew neither. Their guess is that AI has a big advantage in cases like this because it knows all of the mathematical literature, though they said another approach may exist.

Now, the quick hits. The Financial Times reports that Anthropic has agreed to pay about 3.4 billion dollars for gas-fired generators for its data centers. Citing one person who knows about the deal, the FT says it covers 1.7 gigawatts of generating capacity. OnePWR, a power company in San Antonio, had ordered the generators from Caterpillar, and Anthropic took over that purchase. Both companies declined to comment. Anthropic's IPO filing already warns that it may pay above market prices for scarce power equipment to get computing capacity sooner. Google DeepMind says AI agents, working with cryptographers from UC San Diego and Inria, found two new weaknesses in the older 1024-bit version of RSA. One is a forgery method. DeepMind estimates that, only in theory, it is about 1,600 times better than the previous best. The other, for breaking many keys at once, exists only on paper. In the one real run, the agents repeated a known attack with 3.5 times less computing time. DeepMind says 2048-bit keys are not affected. Tencent's chief AI scientist, Yao Shunyu, warned on Saturday that AI's abilities in biology will soon reach the point where it is, in his words, "actually possible to do harm." Yao, a former OpenAI researcher, was speaking in Hong Kong. He said Anthropic makes a strong case for keeping top models closed. Still, he argued for a mix of open and closed models, because open ones help defenders. Tencent plans to release the weights of its new flagship model, Hy4, in the coming days. DeepSeek says Harness, the open-source agent app it launched in August, had 1.54 million daily users on its official API in the week to November 4. At the end of September, it had 271,000. DeepSeek says these users consume about 92 trillion tokens a day, or about 60 million each. That adds up to almost as many tokens per month as Google reported in May for all of its products. Some users say plugins and loops waste many of those tokens. On Thursday, we reported that Apple cut some engineers' AI token budgets. Now Bloomberg's Mark Gurman reports on a closed-door meeting at Apple. He says the new chief executive, John Ternus, told software chief Craig Federighi to speed up Apple's software plans and to go beyond the necessary fixes to Siri. Gurman believes Siri could work more like an agent, similar to OpenAI's Dots, as early as next year. Apple has announced nothing of the kind. John Langford, a veteran Microsoft Research scientist and a former president of the ICML conference, says he has left Microsoft. On his blog, he wrote that AI Frontiers, a lab of about 50 people that he helped start, has ended. In September it was moved into Microsoft AI, whose leaders came from Inflection. Langford says their core philosophy is "scaling, and aggressively not research." He argues that research still pays off. As an example, he points to a design that might match a model twice its size. On Friday, we reported a Claude Code bug that put users' email addresses into web requests. Now the security firm Apiiro has found 1,122 public GitHub files in which Claude Code had saved real passwords and API keys. Developers then committed those files. Boris Cherny, head of Claude Code, says these files should never be committed. He adds that Anthropic is looking at fixes. Friday's jobs report shows that US professional and business services added 70,000 jobs in October. Over the year before, the sector averaged 15,000 a month. Andrew Flowers, chief economist at Appcast, called it a real reversal of the white-collar bloodbath. But the Boston College economist Brian Bethune links recent job gains to federal and election spending. Legal and accounting, two fields often named as exposed to AI, added fewer than 5,000 jobs together.

On Friday, we reported that big investors doubted Anthropic could reach a 1.5 trillion dollar valuation in its IPO. Since then, the expected valuation has fallen again. Bloomberg reports, citing a person familiar with the talks, that some buyers now discuss a valuation of 1.2 to 1.3 trillion dollars. Some go as low as 1.1 trillion. In early October, there was talk of 2 trillion. People disagree about what the lower price means. Some say it shows that AI valuations were too high. Others say it is a normal search for a price that buyers will pay. The skeptics point to supply and politics. The Information counts more than 300 billion dollars of AI stock sold or priced this year, not counting Anthropic. It says about 100 billion more is coming, and asks how much the market can absorb. The research firm Vital Knowledge warns of a vicious cycle: falling AI stocks make data centers harder to fund, and that leads to more selling. On Thursday, two days after the midterms, the Nasdaq had its worst day since April 2025. In those elections, voters rejected data center measures in 40 of 41 cases. Anthropic, meanwhile, has signed almost 900 billion dollars in commitments, mostly for computing power. The other side says a lower price can help. Max Kettner, chief multi-asset strategist at HSBC, rejects the current view in the market that the AI cycle is dead. He says Anthropic's IPO is the biggest chance to change that view. In his opinion, a conservative price, even below one trillion, may be the best way to do it. His worst case is a repeat of SpaceX, whose stock stayed below its offering price for over a month after its June debut. Investing.com argues that a repricing is different from a postponement, and could be a positive signal. Anthropic's revenue reached about 33 billion dollars in the first nine months of the year. Kevin Mahn, chief investment officer at Hennion & Walsh, says a delay would look bearish for AI, and so would a weak debut. In his words: "Damned if you do, damned if you don't." According to the FT, investors say Dario Amodei is determined to go ahead even at a lower valuation. The FT also reports that Anthropic still plans to list before Thanksgiving. CNBC reported that the roadshow is expected to start this week. No price range has been filed yet.

That's the Valley Morning Briefing for Monday, November 9th. If you enjoy the show, the best way to help is to send it to a friend. Thanks for listening, and see you tomorrow.

More episodes from "Valley Morning Briefing"