
Long-Term & Short-Term Property Management: Two Completely Different Businesses | Declan McGonigal
In this episode of Unfiltered, Dylan Scroggins talks with Declan McGonigal, CEO of myBeach Vacation Rentals in Myrtle Beach, South Carolina, about building a property management business across both the long-term and short-term rental markets.
Declan shares how he got into property management, grew his vacation rental portfolio from just a handful of properties to more than 80, and later acquired a long-term management company that now manages around 285 properties. He explains why the two sides of the business operate with completely different teams, technology, and day-to-day demands.
They also dive into the realities of running a highly seasonal short-term rental market, the challenges of relying on platforms like Airbnb, and why property managers need to turn platform guests into direct customers. Declan breaks down when short-term rentals can be a strong revenue opportunity, when the investment may not be worth it, and what owners need to consider before converting a property.
The conversation also explores AI, including where Declan is already seeing meaningful results, why short-term rentals are harder to automate, and why chasing every new AI tool can become a distraction from the biggest bottleneck in your business.
Links
Declan on LinkedIn - / Declan McGonigal | LinkedIn
Dylan on LinkedIn - / Dylan Scroggins | LinkedIn
Matt on LinkedIn - / Matt Speer | LinkedIn
PropertyManagement.com - https://propertymanagement.com/
The Kalmar Group - https://thekalmargroup.com/pm
Subscribe to PropertyManagement.com's weekly Newsletter: https://propertymanagement-com.kit.com/subscribe-to-newsletter
Chapters
01:50–03:58 — From Engineering to 80+ Vacation Rentals
05:34–06:35 — The Airbnb Dependency Problem
07:16–09:14 — Why Airbnb and Zillow Want to Own the Customer
09:43–12:14 — Short-Term vs. Long-Term: Two Different Ball Games
12:33–13:16 — Why Property Managers Love College Guests
19:09–20:59 — When a $1.5M Property Isn't Worth Going Short-Term
22:42–24:23 — Why AI Is Easier to Implement in Long-Term Rentals
25:00–26:09 — AI Can Be a Great Distraction
26:57–30:36 — How Property Management Changed Declan
32:18–32:36 — The Future of Property Management: "Disrupted"
Disclaimer: The content of this podcast is for informational purposes only and does not constitute professional advice. Always perform your own due diligence before making any financial or business decisions.
More episodes from "Unfiltered by PropertyManagement.com"



Don't miss an episode of “Unfiltered by PropertyManagement.com” and subscribe to it in the GetPodcast app.








