
You. Are. Creative. I know that sometimes it can seem as if that’s not true, especially if you’re attempting to work on a creative project for the first time. But I promise you, you are creative.
That’s one of the messages of my guest today, Susan Stirling. Susan is a trauma-sensitive coach with training in somatic approaches to healing. She walks alongside her clients as they explore grief, spirituality, healing, reclaiming narratives and much more.
Susan has been involved with no less than three high-demand organizations, starting when she was just a child in the rocky mountains of the British Columbia Alberta border. But, as she explains, among other things, creativity helped her eventually return to herself.
In the introduction I mention that the International Cultic Studies Association has announced the dates and location for their 2027 conference. The conference will be held in Oslo, Norway on June 24 – 27, 2027. Learn more at InternationalCulticStudies.org.
Susan Stirling works with individuals untangling their own complex histories—especially those navigating patterned self-abandonment, undue influence, or religious trauma. With a trauma-sensitive lens, as well as being a certified coach based on the neuroscience of human development, Susan help others discover the power of small steps, safe connections, and living from the inside out. Learn more at SusanStirling.com
This episode of Creative Alchemy is supported by the audiobook version of my award-winning, Amazon best-selling memoir, Cult, A Love Story.
Readers call the book ‘compelling’ ‘gritty’ ‘intimate’ and ‘not boring’ – which is what an author loves to hear. I narrated the audiobook and if you have a Spotify premium subscription you can listen to the audiobook for free as part of that subscription at alexandraamor.com/spotify.
You can listen above, on your favorite podcast app, or watch on YouTube. Notes, links, resources and a full transcript are below.
Show Notes
- On growing up in a ‘house church’
- Being called to creativity in a prophetic church
- How writing helps us return to ourselves
- Finding the support and encouragement to write a book
- Building a ‘coherent narrative’ as part of the healing process
- Discovering ‘the art of falling’ and why it’s so important to healing
- Living from creativity rather than looking at it like a practice
- Deciding what spirituality means from the inside out
Transcript of the interview with Susan Stirling
Alexandra: Susan Sterling, welcome to Creative Alchemy.
Susan: Thank you, thank you for having me.
Alexandra: Oh, it’s my pleasure to have you on the show.
Give us a little bit about your background and growing up in the church that you were in on the Alberta BC border.
Susan: I guess what I can say or share is that is an incredibly beautiful area. I grew up within a community of family upon family upon generations of family, and so being seen, heard, known was very real for me in many ways of my growing up. So I have to say I’m very grateful for that aspect of my childhood.
Alexandra: Nice. And your family was involved with a church, is that right?
Susan: My mother became involved with a church, so part of my story is no. It was only my mom who took me into some of those house church meetings, and that was part of what actually created the disassociation for me.
Alexandra: I hadn’t heard that expression “house church” until I heard you on a different podcast.
Can you explain what that is?
Susan: Yes. So, think of the time period early ’70s. So, it was at the end of the Jesus People movement, and so at that time, house churching or shepherding movement kind of sort of came into being. There were these offshoots from organized churches.
And so, being in the small town that we were in, what I remember, because I don’t remember all the events of it, but I remember my mom taking me to a house church, where in the living room, you have worship, sing songs with a guitar, and then you have the sermon. Children go off to the room, and then afterwards we may join back into the larger fellowship for prayer or closing or whatever that might be. But the context or the structures were in houses, not necessarily church buildings.
Alexandra: Was it a certain type of church, like a denomination?
Susan: I would say, if looking back now over the storyline of it, it would have come out of the Pentecostal, so very charismatic. Today, I would call it hyper charismatic within that context.
Alexandra: Okay, and you mentioned disassociation. Tell us a little bit about that.
Susan: So in my book and in my story, and I think this is the power of writing as well, which we’ll talk about today, is that it wasn’t until I began to write my story and the context of my story and creating that coherent narrative. When I went back to my childhood and I saw the events that happened, I literally saw myself when I stepped out of a vehicle, my mom’s vehicle that I was sent to because I was bad.
I had a conversation with God in that vehicle, and then when I stepped out of that vehicle, I truly stepped out of parts of myself-the fully integrated part-and I created what I termed a spiritual self and a normal self. In many ways, reading-if you read my story-you would see that a lot of my childhood was normal, growing up in the small town, going to school. But there was this spiritual side of me that developed that was incredibly fear-based and catastrophic-based because I was waiting for the end of the world. Jesus was coming back any day. You had that apocalyptic narrative going on. So I literally split in for survival.
Alexandra: For a young child to be told that the world is ending when I mean you’ve barely got your feet under you. That would be so terrifying.
Susan: It was incredibly overwhelming to my brain nervous system. I think for my story, what’s unique about that to me is it was me and my mom versus the rest of my family would have been left behind. So there’s that context. We weren’t all together going to heaven, getting taken, you know, up and out. There was a lot of mixed and layered to a child’s brain. How do you work that out?
Alexandra: Yeah, exactly, and so you did what worked for you, which is, as you say, is to create these two selves. Very skillful for someone so young.
Susan: That’s what we do, though. That is part of how we survive. That is human.
Alexandra: Exactly. One of the things that I found so interesting about your story is that then in adulthood you became involved in two more sequentially high demand groups. So large group awareness training first, and then another prophetic church community.
When we spoke the first time, you mentioned that in the prophetic church you were ‘called to creativity’, and I was really interested when you said that.
Please tell us about that, what it means, what it looked like, and how it affected your relationship with creativity.
Susan: If I can go back just a little bit and say, because the world didn’t end right as I was always waiting. My brain could only move the markers of life ahead just a little bit because I never knew when the end was coming, and so I became really goal orientated. Well, what can I do before the end?
I graduated high school. Well, I didn’t plan a career and what the future would look like. I would just go, “What can I do now? Oh, maybe I can get married before the end of the world. Maybe I could this before the end of the world.” So I became really goal orientated.
Fast forward into the time of the church and creativity. I remember my husband and I went to the states, and we were becoming friends with a pastor there. One of the things when you become friends with a pastor prophet is you get second row seats. You don’t sit at the back of the church, and so we’re sitting second row seats. In front of us were these dancers, and I had never seen dance in a church up until that point.
At first when worship started and they took up the flags and began to move their bodies across, it was quite annoying to me. I just was, it was, pay attention. I can’t pay attention, but as I settled into them, because they were in front of me and watching them, and they would pick up a flag, and I just began to sob. My spirit, my heart, was connecting to what they were doing. It was bypassing the the logical side of me, and so that was a profound experience.
So I came back to Canada with that, just the experience, nothing else. I went to a church in Edmonton, and there I saw another dancer for the first time in Canada, and she had flags, and she moved, and she did a prophetic drama dance, as we would call it. And again, I just started to bawl, I just started to cry, tears would come. That was my language, but I had no words to put to it.
Those pastors came to our church, brought a prophetic team with them, and they spoke over me, and they said that there was creativity in me, that God wanted to bring it out, and that they asked me, “Do you play an instrument?” And I was like, nope. Do you draw? Nope. And they just said, well, it’s as though music is built in you, and God’s going to take that and use that in this church, et cetera, et cetera. And so that was truly the first knowing from the outside in that God wanted me to have creativity.
Alexandra: What kinds of things did you do for the church in that way?
Susan: I was already part of the worship team. So you could say maybe that’s part of a little bit of creativity. But what I did do was now that I saw flags and dance and drama within from not only in the U.S. but in Canada.
I went to our church, our pastor, and spoke with them and said, “I want to bring this to our body. I want to release this here. I believe God wants me to.” It was like a permission slip, and so that’s what I actually did. I gathered a team of five. At first, they didn’t give me permission to do it. They said, “No, we prayed about it. It’s not time.” So of course, I said, “Okay, well, I’ll listen.”
But then it never went away, and I went back to them, and we were having our first woman’s congregation. And the woman, the female prophetess that spoke in Edmonton, was coming to our church in Calgary, and I felt that it was time. So I went back to them and felt as though God was saying to me, “It’s time”, and they agreed. Hence, I got permission again. So then I gathered a team of five of us, and through that we ministered and created and released truly the prophetic dance.
Alexandra: I’ve never seen a dance like that. I’d be curious what that looks like.
Susan: I still have the videos. It’s the old cassette tapes now.
Alexandra: I’ll have to do a little search on YouTube see if I can find anything.
Susan: You will, yes. Okay. Look up flagging. Yes, you’ll see it.
Alexandra: Okay. Great. So, you’re working in the church and you’re in the creative field, sort of expressing yourself, and then eventually you end up leaving, correct? And so, in your own work that you do now, sort of fast forwarding a little bit again, you talk about returning to ourselves.
Maybe you could talk to us about how you discovered the importance of that and how writing helps us to return to ourselves.
Susan: For me, returning to myself when I speak about it in the context of my work and writing, understanding as I’ve written my story out is how much I lived from the outside in. I really wanted to begin to live from the inside out. And my question was, how do I do that?
For me, what happened was I needed beginning to live or return to myself was actually integrating my experiences that had happened to me, which allowed me to reclaim my story. Which then allowed me to begin to live in greater self-trust, self-compassion, right, and really live an authentic life, rather than hiding parts of myself or being fragmented.
Alexandra: Did that begin with journaling or anything like that?
Susan: I would like to say yes, but no, it didn’t. It actually came through my experience.
When I was in the church, one of the things we did-that’s where writing began to take on a meaning for me because we learned to hear God, and in hearing God is when I would begin to write out what I would believe God was saying and put those pieces together. So my creative act of writing actually started within the church. I always had a way of words, but I wouldn’t say that I, again, I was goal and action orientated versus really sit and and looking outside of myself rather than going inside of myself.
Alexandra: Your book is called Velcro Kisses, which I just love that title.
When did you first have the idea to write that book?
Susan: When I met my second husband. Pre husbandy, when we were dating, I had to tell him my story. I felt I was, you know, I’ve met somebody. I’m falling in love. It’s new. It’s exciting, and I didn’t want to hide parts of myself or of my story. I’ve had that happen to me. I know the effects of that, and so I just sat with him and said, “Before we fall in love, I think you need to know this about me.”
When I shared parts of my story, the larger picture, I was met with compassion. He said to me, “Wow, you need to write your story.” His name is Andrew. Andrew didn’t say that from a wow. Maybe that’ll be a dream one day. His mom was actually a two-time author, and he helped her write her stories. And she didn’t write her stories until she was in her 60s. So he knows what it’s like to be in the presence of someone who takes time to carve that out.
So that’s how the thought of writing really, truly taking the time to because up until then, I you know I lived, I was in survival, I worked. Then Velcro kisses came from… I was working with it. I had already started. Andrew and I were married. One of the things he suggested is just take the next year. His mom had passed, and she’d left him some inheritance. And he said, “Why don’t you take the next year, and I’ll give you this money, parts of this money, so that you feel you have time, space, and support to write.”
So I did, and as I was taking that time to write my story, I was working with somebody, a trauma coach, a religious trauma coach actually, and she had showed me a video or Instagram clip on trauma bonds. When I would see it, it was a dance. It was two dancers come together, which again dance. This man would take this woman and shake her violently and pull her to him and kiss her passionately, and then push her away and shake her some more, and then bring her.
As I was watching that, all I could think of maybe it was the dance involved who knows, but all I could think of was that’s what I was like with prophecy. That was my experience in church. That’s the attachment that I had to what you know what prophecy and was held over my life. Hence, Velcro kisses.
Alexandra: That yeah, drawing in and pushing away. First of all, I just want to say that was so kind of your husband to give you that kind of support and just acknowledge that it was important that you do this thing. So kudos to him.
As you began to write, what sort of challenges did you experience? Was it easy right from the get go?
Susan: I would say yes and no. Yes, in the sense that I was ready to write my story. It had been mulling inside of me for years, and so having that opportunity to take time and space. I actually just left the clinic setting that I was working in for over 10 years. I believed I was carving out time to sit to do it.
So yes, I got to do it, but it was also tricky because number one, COVID had hit two years prior, and I was having anxiety attacks. I knew that some of the trauma was still alive in me. But leaving the clinic setting that I was in, it was also activating it. Not because the clinic itself was the issue; it’s because I hadn’t processed my experience. I was just taking the template of how I attached to church and laying it over my workplace.
Coming out of that, triggers were happening, and then I fell, had a fall, and broke my wrist. It was my right wrist, so my dominant wrist. Those were some of the trickiness of writing my story because falling meant failing to me, and so in all of that, I took the triggers, I took the broken bones, which presented much more than broken bones, and I used that pain to really dive into the pain that was going on inside of myself.
That’s when I really discovered the fragmented parts, but also the mountain of grief that I had buried and spiritually bypassed, and all of those things that we do when we are in cults and high control groups, and we don’t know what to do with it. I took that experience, and when I was able to write again, I was able to really build that coherent narrative for myself.
Alexandra: I love that you use this phrase, coherent narrative.
This seems like a good spot for you to tell us more about what that means to you and to the people that you work with.
Susan: For me, coherent narrative is. I like to use the analogy in my book. I use threads, but I like to use just an everyday example that people can relate to is of a movie. And so, say building a coherent narrative is like having pieces of the script or film, pieces of that film, pieced all over the floor.
What coherent narrative means to me is taking and looking at that piece or that clip or whatever it might be, really looking at it, and looking at it is one thing, but looking at it in the context of the larger framework-that’s what’s building a coherent narrative to me. It’s taking those fragments, taking those snapshots, looking at them, naming them, giving language to them, really knowing what that is.
Then it’s looking at that larger picture and saying that belongs here, that belongs there. Before then, it was just kind of going all over the place within me, and so putting it together in a coherent narrative for me, especially it was with prophecy. I saw the story of my life with it, and seeing the story of my life with it, it then allowed me to see it, name it, make sense of it, understand it, grieve it, but then say, “This is where I want to go from here.”
Alexandra: Did someone help you with that process or were you doing it for yourself?
Susan: Some yes and no. I did have the religious trauma coach in the beginning. However, I was so used to being in environments that I became part of, so I would absorb the environment. I would absorb the flavour, the texture, the voice. I actually ended up hibernating, really secluding, isolating myself in a good way, so that I could begin to hear my own voice, my own thoughts.
Because I would, it was in the beginning. I thought, oh well, maybe I’ll read this book, and then and then I was writing how that author was writing. It wasn’t me at all, and so I purposed to take it and to literally spend time getting to know what my voice looked like, sounded like, felt like, so that I could tune into the authenticity inside of me and find that sense of self.
Alexandra: Oh, that’s such a beautiful story! I love hearing that. It feels like in any creative project, there’s always a phase where we are following those who have gone before us and learning from other people. And then it does feel like there’s a point where we have to stop and just find our own voice, as you said.That’s so great.
So you had this-would you call it a setback- with your broken wrist and your fall and that kind of thing?
But it sounds like what had happened was it led you deeper into discovering who you were.
Susan: It did. So it wasn’t just a one-time break. It was actually a two-time break. I broke my wrist, and then seven months later, I was riding my bike to my physio appointment to assess my bike and fell again, and unfortunately broke my hip. And so it was pinned.
Then I needed a hip replacement. In all of that, what it actually amplified was how much meaning making I would place to everyday something happening to me. Also that falling meant failing, and I really spiraled. I could see the shame spiral, and so I actually termed it learning to do the art of falling.
That’s part of what I work with people, is just taking those things that we think we failed and the pain of it, and reframing it, and bringing us up and out of it again. Not saying it didn’t happen because those months, they were deep, deep months where I wondered whether I would actually write my story. Do I have it in me to write my story? And yes, I did.
Alexandra: Yes, you did. That’s exactly right.
When you started doing that, did you have a regular writing practice? I like to ask this for our listeners so they feel inspired by what others are doing,
Susan: When I started writing my story, my writing practice, I was all in. I did it almost every day wherever I went.
One thing about it is, my husband when he would work away, I could still drive my vehicle so I would meet him where he would be at. I would take all my writing with me and sometimes he would leave me in the morning and come home in the afternoon and I would still be at my computer just writing.
I think the other thing I’d like to share is when I first first wrote my story, I hand wrote it because it used one part of the brain, and then I actually put it on my computer. I used that other part of the brain because I really wanted to process through the emotional parts.
Alexandra: That’s such a good point, and it’s something I wrestle with all the time because younger people now don’t write longhand. I do think it accesses just like you said, another part of the brain, another part of our being. That’s so fascinating.
And what about right now? Do you have a creativity practice now?
Susan: What’s interesting in this whole process is creativity actually is now a core value. So I live from it rather than simply practicing it.
Alexandra: Say more about that. What does that look like?
Susan: It’s an everyday thing, and in many ways. I don’t look to carve out time to practice my creativity, I am looking at life from a creative perspective, which means whether it’s my paints, I have crayons, I have whatever. It could be even how I’m going to choose to dress that day or something. So creativity for me, I’ve chosen to make it because it is such a big part of who I am-a core value-and that’s something we live from.
Alexandra: How does that manifest itself in your life? Are you working on any other writing projects, or what?
What does that look like?
Susan: Yes. So when you say writing projects, I have a Substack. In public, so in publishing my book, I self-published, and what was suggested to me was because I was not on social media, I was not on platforms. That’s not necessarily my personality, and so they were talking about having a presence in the world, so people could just find you.
It’s not about having you being out there, but allowing people to find you. I thought one way that would be authentic to me would be Substack. I have a Substack account. I love sitting down, and I call it my word dump. I don’t write every day, but I’ll sit down and I’ll just take musings that have been going on inside of me, and it’s amazing to see what comes out for an article.
I have taken things from tidbits to threads. In my book, I did talk about prophecy, mainly the prophecies in my life, but there’s also satanic panic. There were conspiracy theories. I took those tidbits and made longer articles in them.
Spirituality has been a big thing. So then I just broadened that because I didn’t give up. Some people who come out of what I’ve come out, they go into whatever they choose to go into. I chose to keep spirituality. I just know that for me, that that is something that’s important. But I wanted to ground it, so I created a whole or a series on grounded spirituality and what that means to me.
Substack is my fun place right now. I don’t know if you have Substack or if you have blogs, but if I have a writing practice, that’s my writing practice.
Alexandra: Oh, that’s so nice, and it’s nice that it’s for you, but it’s also for others at the same time, right?
I want to go back and touch on this idea that you held on to your spirituality because I think it’s complicated when we come out of a high demand religion or group. I really admire that you were able to hold on to that part of yourself. I know for me, there was a long while where I had essentially thrown the baby out with the bathwater, even though spirituality was really important to me. I was so injured by what had happened that I just couldn’t imagine keeping that part of me alive. So, for our listeners, it’s very personal.
How do you think you were able to do that? Keep that connection.
Susan: It’s changed. I will say that it has changed. I no longer hold the concepts that I did hold, but for me, because two reasons.
I had experienced incredibly, it was energetics, it was real, it was transcendent, it was all of those things that I couldn’t fake or make up. Some people say, “Well, that’s just your brain.” Maybe yes, maybe no.
The other thing is because it was part of me that I had created, right? I had disassociated. What was going to heal me was integration. For a time I thought, well, I’m just going to go back to normal self. I’m just going to strengthen my normal self.
But I found it incredibly lonely because so much of my life included spirituality. So when I integrated it, I then could decide what spirituality meant for me, not from the outside in, but from the inside out.
Alexandra: Right. Oh, that’s so powerful. I’m writing it down. Integrating all those parts of ourselves is more important than dismissing the ones that we might be afraid of or that might cause us discomfort. Such a good point. I’m going to have to sit with that for a while.
As we start to wrap up the interview, is there anything else you’d like to share about creative inspiration or creative alchemy, as I call it, that we haven’t touched on.
Susan: I think one thing, if I when it as it relates to my story about creativity, and for the people who are listening, is that in my story, creativity came from the outside in. So when it came from the outside in, it meant for in my life, it was conditional, so it could be taken away. And it was taken away for a while until I decided to take it back.
In my journey of my story, I believe that creativity is in every single person’s DNA on this planet because we came from an egg that met a sperm, right? So it was a creative act. So how that creative act, what that creative act, might look different for each one of us, whether it’s writing, painting, art, thinking in a unique way, and it’s we get to find out what that’s like for us when we choose to live from the inside out. So, if I can add that to anybody or say that, it’s life changing tapping into creativity.
Alexandra: Oh, beautiful! Thank you for sharing that. I love it.
Susan: You’re welcome.
Alexandra: We’ll remind our listeners that your book is called Velcro Kisses.
Please let our audience know where they can find out more about you and your work.
Susan: Simply two places. I have a website, so just my name, susanstirling.com, and I have a Substack article under Seeing Susan. But if you go to my website, it will link right into Substack.
Alexandra: Okay, great, that’s awesome. I will put links in the show notes to both those things. Thank you, Susan. It’s been so nice connecting with you and a fellow British Columbian.
Susan: Yes, yes.
Before we go, Alexandra, I just want to say publicly that I was so excited to be invited to get to speak with you because you and your story and how you wrote your story was one of the very first books and stories that I read as I came out into my deconstructing journey. I loved that you shared your story versus told your story. So I really want to thank you for that.
Alexandra: Oh, you’re so welcome. Thank you so much for saying that. I appreciate it.
Well, take care, and we’ll talk to you again soon.
Susan: Take care. Thank you. Bye bye.
Click here to grab your complimentary copy of the Creative Alchemy journaling handbook.
The post Reclaiming Our Innate Creativity with Susan Stirling appeared first on Alexandra Amor Books.
More episodes from "Creative Alchemy"



Don't miss an episode of “Creative Alchemy” and subscribe to it in the GetPodcast app.








