Track Changes On Podcast podcast

When Company Logic Defies Common Sense

0:00
18:24
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds

Episode summary: Why the Worst Business Decisions All Fail This Simple Test

Why do so many companies keep making decisions that seem to defy common sense? Some of the worst business decisions aren’t necessarily made by inexperienced or incompetent people. Often, there’s a perfectly rational explanation for how the company got there.

This episode of Track Changes On looks at why business fails and corporate fails can happen even when the individual decisions behind them make sense. We look at the organisational research behind local rationality and goal displacement, and how breaking complex problems into smaller pieces can sometimes leave nobody looking at the whole picture. 

We also look at what these decisions tell us about corporate culture and leadership, using the Australian idea of the ‘pub test’ to ask a simple question: does this decision still make sense when you step outside the organisation and look at the whole picture? It’s a useful way to understand some of the contradictions that make corporate culture so frustrating for the people working inside it. 

In this episode

* Why rational corporate decisions can produce outcomes that seem absurd

* What the Australian ‘pub test’ can tell us about corporate decision-making

* Famous business fails that made sense internally but failed the common sense test

* Why Netflix’s Qwikster decision became such a high-profile corporate failure

* What Vegemite iSnack 2.0 can teach us about internal corporate logic

* Why companies break complex decisions into smaller pieces

* How local rationality can make each piece of a decision seem reasonable while the overall outcome doesn’t

* Why following the right corporate process doesn’t necessarily produce the right outcome

* The role leadership teams play in stepping back and looking at the whole picture

* Why social media has effectively become the modern version of the pub test

Research referenced in this episode

Richard M. Cyert and James G. March, A Behavioral Theory of the Firm (1963). Cyert and March’s work helps explain the idea of local rationality. Large organisations manage complexity by dividing problems between different parts of the business, each working with its own goals, information and constraints. This can mean individual decisions make sense within a particular function while their combined effect is less rational when viewed across the organisation as a whole. 

Robert K. Merton, Bureaucratic Structure and Personality (1940), Social Forces. Merton’s work on bureaucratic structures introduced the concept of goal displacement. Rules and processes created to achieve an objective can gradually become objectives in themselves, with adherence to the process taking precedence over whether it produces the intended outcome. 

Herbert A. Simon, A Behavioral Model of Rational Choice (1955), Quarterly Journal of Economics. Simon’s work on bounded rationality explains why people and organisations rely on simplified models, procedures and ‘good enough’ solutions rather than considering every possible consequence of a decision. In large organisations, those structures help people manage complexity but can also narrow what individual decision-makers see and consider relevant. 

Supporting the show

If you enjoy my work and would like to support it, here are a few things I’ve created:

🛒 Track Changes On Shop - Coffee mugs for corporate rebels

📖 Do Give Up Your Day Job - Guide to corporate exits and transitions to self-employment

Subscribe

Subscribe to Track Changes On for weekly conversations about the future of corporate work, AI, careers and organisational change.

Connect with me elsewhere

📸 Instagram | 🧵 Threads | 🔗 LinkedIn



Get full access to Track Changes On at www.trackchangeson.com/subscribe

More episodes from "Track Changes On Podcast"