Hour 2: The Origin of the Rubber Match

Carton is furious that the basketball hall of fame elected a bunch of compilers this year. Plus, Giancarlo sits and Yankee fans won't have access to tampons in the mens room. It's the baseball term that most people know when we come to the third game of a split series, the rubber Match. But where does it come from?

Carton is furious that the basketball hall of fame elected a bunch of compilers this year. Plus, Giancarlo sits and Yankee fans won't have access to tampons in the mens room.

It's the baseball term that most people know when we come to the third game of a split series, the rubber Match. But where does it come from?

The New York Yankees are just FIVE games into the season… and fans are already calling for trades?! Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle react to some early overreactions, including takes on Jasson Domínguez, the rotation, and whether the Yankees should make moves this early.

Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle dive into one of the wildest off-field stories of the season, an update on the tampon controversy at New York Yankees games ahead of Opening Day at Yankee Stadium. What’s actually happening and what changed? Plus, the guys keep the debate rolling on the controversial Basketball Hall of Fame class, including opinions on Doc Rivers and Amar'e Stoudemire.

The New York Yankees are off to a scorching start in 2026 and their pitching staff might already be the BEST in baseball. Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle break down the Yankees' early dominance, including a stellar outing from Max Fried and surprising contributions across the rotation and bullpen.

It may not be accurate, but the message of positivity that Aaron Glenn is sending to his team is the right message. Unfortunately, no one believes that he's on the path to success. That's right, Mark Messier wasn't important at all when it comes down to the New York Rangers winning the Stanley Cup in 1994! Plus, Disney adults are real. Chris McMonigle embarrasses himself on live radio as he loses a game "Do you know you know more sports than a 7 year old". Also, Tiger Woods is caught with pills, but the media doesn't care about that, how's his golf game? Jerry Recco makes a surprise phone call to the Carton Show after we discovered some scungilli at the office. Plus, for the first time in the history of WFAN the ladies take over the airwaves!

It may not be accurate, but the message of positivity that Aaron Glenn is sending to his team is the right message. Unfortunately, no one believes that he's on the path to success.

That's right, Mark Messier wasn't important at all when it comes down to the New York Rangers winning the Stanley Cup in 1994! Plus, Disney adults are real.

Chris McMonigle embarrasses himself on live radio as he loses a game "Do you know you know more sports than a 7 year old". Also, Tiger Woods is caught with pills, but the media doesn't care about that, how's his golf game?