Thoughts on the Market podcast

Europe's AI Moment

0:00
13:06
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds

Recorded at Morgan Stanley's European Tech, Media and Telecom Conference in Barcelona, our analysts discuss data center rollout, Europe's push for sovereign AI, the rise of agentic AI and the race for power efficiency. The episode features Paul Walsh, Head of European Research, Emmett Kelly, Head of European Telco and Data Centers, and Lee Simpson, Head of European Technology Hardware

Read more insights from Morgan Stanley.


----- Transcript -----

Paul Walsh: Welcome to Thoughts on the Markets. I'm Paul Walsh, Morgan Stanley's head of European research, and we're bringing you a special episode today from Morgan Stanley's twenty-sixth European TMT conference, currently underway. And the central themes we're focused on today relate to the data center rollout story, the need for sovereign AI, the rise of AI agents, and of course, the power shortfall, and the potential shift in focus towards power efficiency.

I'm joined by my colleagues, Emmet Kelly, head of European Telco and Data Centers here in Europe, and Lee Simpson, head of European Technology Hardware. It's Thursday, November the 19th at 8:00 AM in Barcelona.

It's fantastic to have you here we've got over a hundred and sixty corporates, over five hundred investors registered from over two hundred and fifty different, institutions. What an opportune moment for us to reflect on the wider TMT space, given some of the market moves that we've seen in recent months. And so would love to hear both your thoughts on maybe four, key thematic areas that I think are very much in focus.

Emmett, let's start with the data center rollout question. It's something you and the global team have talked about in your research. We've talked about funding constraints and how that impacts the rate of rollout and an increasing shift in focus from investors from 2027 to 2028. What have you learned on that topic?

Emmett Kelly: Yeah, data centers are front and center at the TMT conference here in Barcelona this week.

I think, looking back over the last couple of years, there have been two main constraints: power and planning.

Power is getting access to energy cheap and fast, and planning is getting proposals approved by local government and central government. Now we see new constraints emerging, and those constraints are politics so we've had a change in the United States after the midterm elections. And then financing getting access to capital to build data centers is becoming an area of blockage. In our recent report, we added another constraint onto data center build, which was price.

We've noticed very, very heavy inflation in building data centers. We estimate that the cost of building a data center is up twelve percent year on year, and we expect this inflation rate to accelerate to fifteen percent next year and the year after. In terms of what's happening in the United States, our view and our feedback that we've received is, kind of threefold.

Firstly, where there are shovels in the ground, those projects will continue uninhibited, and those data centers will get built. Therefore, we think data center capacity growth in the States will be very strong in twenty twenty-seven. However, there will be a consultation period between data center builders and the new administration looking at areas such as planning permission, unionized labor, usage of water, use of renewables, et cetera.

And this could drive a slight slowdown in data center build in twenty twenty-eight, and that will roll forward into twenty twenty-nine. In terms of the kind of second implication, our view is that data centers will build wherever they can. So tech companies are very, very mobile. If they can't build in location A, they will move to location B.

So where would location B? That would be other states within the US that would be more planning permission friendly. And also there could be some spillover into other countries and there could be an opportunity here for European data center builders and beyond that into Asia, where we've earmarked countries such as South Korea, India, and other Asian countries where you could see greater than expected data center build.

Paul Walsh: And Lee, coming to you with the same question, what are your observations?

Lee Simpson: Yeah. I think that's absolutely correct. I don't think anyone's querying the near-term demand. Really the debate is how can we look out to '28? How can we be comfortable that we have a build-out story that still has momentum, still has growth? So everyone's querying the order book, how resilient is this? How fixed are those orders, and what could evaporate if indeed the market turns a little sour, depending on what the climate would be at that point.

Paul Walsh: Understood. So, I wanted to talk about sovereign AI capability here in Europe, both in terms of compute capacity but also in terms of frontier or open source model capability. Again, Emmett, what are you hearing on that front from your meetings today?

Emmett Kelly: So data sovereignty has been a core discussion point here again this year.

This was also the case last year because we've had huge shifts in geopolitics over the last couple of years. There is a viewpoint that Europe needs its own data centers for its own data. Europe has got huge flows of very sensitive data, in particular in industries such as banking and finance, government, pharmaceuticals, aviation, defense, military, and this information needs to be hosted on sovereign European platforms.

And these platforms need to be sovereign from top to bottom, from the software layer all the way down to the physical data center. A number of telcos are now beginning to build data centers, and despite the fact that data centers are becoming more expensive to build, the feeling in Europe is the demand from corporates for data center capacity is really quite insatiable.

It's growing. There's very good pricing power in the industry. So telcos, they're a little bit late to the game, but they are starting to build their own data center infrastructure.

Paul Walsh: I'd agree. I think this notion of, there still being time to establish sovereign capabilities in Europe is a message that I think has come across, in a number of the different presentation tracks that we've attended.

Something that Morgan Stanley Research has written a lot about is the rise of agentic AI. And it's notable to me that this is something which is being talked about pretty much in every meeting. So Lee, What are your insights into the agentic piece from the meetings you've had today?

Lee Simpson: So I think agentic AI is a really interesting space, and just to level set everyone, the way we think about it is it's a little bit akin to an application moment on the smartphone.

So where you see apps coming, we're gonna see agents coming for cloud AI and maybe even at the edge eventually as well. But what's happening at the compute level is you're seeing a separation of the layers. There's a compute layer that will carry on being done by the GPU, but the orchestration, particularly inference, is going to move to a CPU, and that CPU is going to be the new compute resource driven by this greater use. But in the main, agentic AI is delivering a huge new capability set, for both enterprise, and other general users alike. So agentic AI is a theme that's big here this year. No surprise really. I imagine it'll feature again next year, frankly, and, something that we're seeing most of our companies lean into.

Emmett Kelly: Yeah, I think telcos are becoming a little bit more comfortable in how they view agentic AI. So there is a transition taking place at the moment. There's three steps of AI that telcos are cognizant of. The first step is generative AI, the second step is agentic AI, and the third step is physical AI. So agentic AI is the one in the middle.

Now, telcos, by and large, seem willing to engage with agents. So some of the largest telcos have said they will deploy their own agents to deal with third-party agents, but their agents, so the telco agents, will not negotiate with the agentic AI agents. The second takeaway was telcos that have got best network or are the best value feel that agentic AI could actually present an opportunity for them.

So if agentic AI does trigger churn and customers moving between telcos, the operators with the best network feel that they can win market share, because one of the most common customer complaints in telcos is, "My network isn't very good." So the best networks can win market share. There is a feeling that the one area you do not want to be is stuck in the middle. So you either want to have best network or offer better value, best value, but you don't want to be an operator with an average network and average prices, because in an agentic AI world, you might get squeezed.

Paul Walsh: And, and the other thing, maybe this is an extension of that, is the migration of AI to edge applications as well. What have you heard around that?

Lee Simpson: Yeah. I think at some point we will be transferring much of this back out to the edge. What we've done in the cloud will come to the edge, and here it will have to a lot more power efficient.

It'll have to be secure if you're going to run agentic AI, at the edge. So the possibility again that some of the compute architectures have to change to allow for that security. It is not something that's front and center yet, can see that it's lurking maybe 12, 18 months off as a, as a theme.

Paul Walsh: And finally, Emmett, from my side, the power shortfall, is one of the limitations that you and the global team have written about extensively in terms of data center rollout. But one of the things that does do is shift the focus towards power efficiency, and efficiency more broadly, as we're adding more and more compute.

Would love to hear your thoughts on what you're hearing?

Emmett Kelly: So power has been the greatest constraint in the data center world for the last five years. And to give you an indication of where data center usage of power can go, you just need to look at the Irish data center market. Ireland now sees twenty-five percent of its national grid capacity used by data centers.

It's the most advanced data center market in the world on a per pop basis, but it just shows how power-hungry data centers are.

The feedback I've had from the TMT conference is that data center owners would, in an ideal world, like to have access to nuclear energy. Nuclear comes with a very big base load.

It comes with potential behind-the-fence pricing. It comes with water and security as well. However, in, let's say, the real world, my feeling is that data center owners would like to have a smorgasbord of power solutions. So they'd like to have a mix of grid, backup with batteries, maybe some access to nuclear, renewable energy, wind, solar.

It's a combination of different, power solutions. But power is definitely going to remain front and center of the data center debate in Europe. To get a grid connection in the UK can take between five and eight years. Some countries are very much at the forefront of offering power solutions to data center operators, and I would highlight France and Finland as markets where the power offering is ahead of other European countries.

Lee Simpson: I mean, power is, it's a huge currency in AI, be it in the supply of power to the data center, be it in the efficient use across the data center, particularly in the server rack, or even at the edge device.

All of this is going to continue as a theme, and I think this will roll for, many years to come. The sort of things that we're hearing at this point is in the server rack will be new power architectures. Of course, everybody knows there's an 800-volt architecture coming at some point. This will involve, new compound semis like silicon carbide and gallium nitride, but also new device architectures closer to the processor, so you can deliver power or even voltage potential much closer to that efficiently. As you mentioned, we've got to think about the actual delivery of grid to the data center as well and perhaps also, if indeed AI moves out to the edge, particularly on phones or other edge devices, that compute has to be done much more efficiently because you're gonna be limited by a lithium-ion battery.

And on top of that, it has to be done securely. So a, a lot of evolution around power efficiency to come. Certainly a theme that's not going away.

Paul Walsh: Yeah. Certainly an area of innovation for sure. Emmett, Lee, thanks very much for joining me as always.

Lee Simpson: Thank you.

Emmett Kelly: Thanks very much, Paul.

Paul Walsh: And thank you for listening. Let us know what you think about this and other episodes by leaving us a review wherever you get your podcasts. And if you enjoy Thoughts on the Market, please tell a friend or colleague to tune in today.

More episodes from "Thoughts on the Market"