The Scotchy Bourbon Boys podcast

Blind Tasting The Most Hyped 12-Year Bourbons

0:00
1:32:00
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds

Send us Fan Mail

We go fully blind with four famous 12-year bourbons and learn fast that our noses and palates do not care about price tags or prestige. Knob Creek 12 takes the win while Van Winkle Lot B surprises us in the worst way, sparking a blunt talk about hype, batches and what “overrated” really means. 
• Studio updates and weekend talk before the pours 
• Setting up a four-way blind with wives pouring the glasses 
• Quick facts on Evan Williams 12, Weller 12, Knob Creek 12 and Van Winkle Lot B 
• Nosing round with big caramel, cherry, dusty oak and vanilla notes 
• Palate round chaos with water breaks and shifting impressions 
• The reveal and why the rankings shock us 
• Debating whether Van Winkle Lot B is overrated or just off-profile 
• What blind tasting teaches about marketing, rarity and secondary prices 
• Barrel bottle breakdown of Knob Creek 12 with nose, body, taste and finish scoring 
• Knob Creek 12 cask strength as a “next level” pour 
• Future ideas including a 10-year theme and a Wild Turkey 101 Thanksgiving revisit 
Remember, www.scotchybourbonboys.com for all things Scotchy Bourbon Boys 
Whether you listen to us or watch us, make sure you leave us good feedback, like five-star reviews 
Get your orders in for the bourbon balls 

We pull four 12-year bourbons off the hype train, cover the labels, and let our noses and palates do the talking. The lineup sounds like a collector’s flex: Weller 12, Van Winkle Special Reserve 12 Year Lot B, Evan Williams 12, and Knob Creek 12. What we get instead is a reality check about how bourbon actually tastes when the branding disappears and you stop “drinking the label.”  

We start by laying out the basics bourbon fans search for: distilleries, proofs, mash bill chatter, and what a 12-year age statement really guarantees (and what it absolutely does not). Then we run a true blind tasting with four glasses labelled by colour, working through a dedicated nose round and a palate round with water breaks. Notes swing from rich caramel, cherry and vanilla to dusty oak, char, leather, and one glass that hits us with a weird grapey, floral, perfumey aftershave vibe that throws the whole table into confusion.  

When we reveal the identities, the results are the kind that spark arguments in group chats. Knob Creek 12 rises to the top, Evan Williams 12 punches way above its reputation, Weller 12 lands in the middle, and Van Winkle Lot B ends up dead last on our cards. From there we go deeper on the real question: does losing blind mean “overrated,” a bad batch, or simply a mismatch with our evolving palate? We close with a full barrel bottle breakdown of Knob Creek 12 and a quick detour into Knob Creek 12 cask strength as a potential game changer.  

If you love blind bourbon tastings, allocated bourbon debates, and honest whiskey reviews that cut through secondary market noise, hit subscribe, share this with a bourbon friend, and leave us a five-star review so more people can find the show.

If You Have Gohsts

Support the show

https://www.scotchybourbonboys.com

The Scotchy bourbon Boys are #3 in Feedspots Top 60 whiskey podcasts in the world    https://podcast.feedspot.com/whiskey_podcasts/


More episodes from "The Scotchy Bourbon Boys"