The Rational Believer podcast

Does Science Make God Unnecessary?

0:00
18:44
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds

Does science make God unnecessary? If God is just the name for whatever science hasn't explained yet, every discovery shrinks Him. This episode takes the "God of the gaps" objection at full strength, and argues it defeats one picture of God while missing another.


Medieval church bells were cast with the words "Fulgura frango": "I break the lightning." Then Benjamin Franklin showed that lightning was electrical, and today churches put lightning rods on their own steeples. I let the skeptic make the strongest case (Laplace: "I had no need of that hypothesis"), and separate two questions that keep getting mixed up: how the world works, and why there is a world with laws at all.


This series doesn't assume Islam is true and argue backward. The conclusions have to earn their place.


0:00 I break the lightning

1:16 Is God just a placeholder for the gaps?

3:15 The God who keeps retreating

4:33 The skeptic at full strength: Laplace

5:38 Mechanism and meaning: the letter

6:56 The Qur'an doesn't force the choice

7:58 Ibn al-Khaṭīb and the plague

8:42 Explanation doesn't kill wonder

10:19 God doesn't live where science hasn't arrived

11:29 So what does God explain?

13:50 Have we just renamed the mystery?

14:57 What the believer gives up

16:05 Back to the bell ringers

17:27 Next time: is the universe fine-tuned?


Referenced: Qur'an 30:48, 57:3, 3:190 · Georges Lemaître · Pierre-Simon Laplace · Ibn al-Khaṭīb · John Keats · Albert Einstein, "Physics and Reality" (1936) · Stephen Hawking, A Brief History of Time (1988)


Watch on YouTube: https://youtu.be/xZMC0uKzJgY


You should not have to choose between your intellect and your soul.

More episodes from "The Rational Believer"