The Private Equity Podcast, by Raw Selection podcast

Underwrite the CEO Before the Company

0:00
16:42
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds

Alex Rawlings is joined by Ian Reynolds, Founder of Thesis Capital, to discuss why private equity firms should put leadership at the centre of their investment decisions. Drawing on his experience across transactional finance, $10 billion in deals and operating businesses, Ian explains how Thesis Capital approaches acquisitions by evaluating the CEO, management team and operational realities before committing capital.

Ian shares why fragmented deal teams can miss critical risks, how behavioural assessments help identify exceptional operators, and why investors should underwrite downside risks before getting carried away with growth assumptions.


Key Takeaways

  • Underwrite the CEO first: In the lower middle market, leadership is often the key differentiator between otherwise similar businesses.
  • Break down investment silos: End-to-end deal ownership helps investors understand the commercial, financial and operational realities of an acquisition.
  • Assess behavioural characteristics: Emotional intelligence, ethical judgement, adaptability, communication and a hands-on mindset are essential CEO qualities.
  • Put operators into due diligence: Experienced executives can identify management skill gaps and determine whether the existing team can deliver the next stage of growth.
  • Test whether a business can scale: Thesis Capital looks for businesses capable of growing at approximately twice the rate of GDP, potentially through vertical integration or horizontal expansion.
  • Underwrite the downside first: Identifying what could go wrong helps investors avoid unrealistic assumptions and build more robust investment cases.
  • Think in mental models: Inspired by Charlie Munger, Ian views businesses as biological organisms rather than simply financial instruments.


Timestamps

00:00 – Introduction to Ian Reynolds and Thesis Capital
01:00 – The mistake private equity firms make with deal teams
03:00 – Why Thesis Capital underwrites the CEO first
04:30 – What financial statements miss about operational challenges
06:00 – How to identify a great CEO and operator
07:30 – The behavioural traits Thesis Capital looks for in leaders
10:00 – What operators uncover during management due diligence
12:00 – Assessing whether a business can scale
14:00 – Why companies struggle to grow beyond their market
15:30 – Underwriting the investment case before closing
17:30 – Avoiding overly optimistic assumptions
19:00 – Charlie Munger’s mental models and business strategy
20:00 – How to connect with Ian Reynolds and Thesis Capital

Raw Selection partners with Private Equity firms and their portfolio companies to secure exceptional executive talent. We focus on de-risking executive recruitment through meticulous search and selection processes, ensuring top-tier performance and long-term success.

🔗 Connect with Alex Rawlings on LinkedIn https://www.linkedin.com/in/alexrawlings/
🌐 Visit Raw Selection www.raw-selection.com



More episodes from "The Private Equity Podcast, by Raw Selection"