
The first time David Rogier swiped an American Express card, he was buying groceries at Ralph’s, and he was thrilled. Then the card worked exactly like his debit card. Same swipe, same receipt, same groceries.
“The transaction itself was a letdown,” he told me. “But emotionally, I liked how I felt.”
I know the feeling. The first thing I ever bought with a Platinum card was a footlong at Subway. The sandwich was no different. I was. Now I’m a baller.
That’s the whole game, and it’s what this episode is about. Money is the most fungible thing on earth, and we still feel differently depending on whose logo is on the plastic. A Coke isn’t only cold and fizzy. It comes with 125 years of the Olympics, the World Cup, polar bears and summer, and you can’t separate the drink from the story. The interesting question isn’t whether that meaning is fake. It’s why we’re so embarrassed to admit it’s real.
David is one of my oldest friends (we were classmates at WashU), an early investor in At Present (full disclosure for our SEC listeners), and a happy customer. This episode drifts further from jewelry than most. It also gets closer than most to the question underneath the whole show: why do we want what we want?
Is a hike really better than a Coke?
David proposed a thought experiment. A hike gives you three joy points. A Coke gives you three joy points. Our culture has quietly ruled that the hike counts for more. But if the point of life is to find joy and help other people, why do we care so much where the joy comes from?
My theory is that we treat some needs as solid (a roof, dinner on the table, meaningful work) and dismiss everything in between as frippery. But we were sitting in David’s beautifully arranged living room at the time, and I’d argue that room does more for him than four walls ever could.
The best education is entertainment
In the early days, everyone asked MasterClass the same question: are you entertainment or education? It used to make David almost angry, until he realized the question itself was the problem. The best education is entertaining. So why can’t a lesson look as good as a Scorsese film?
When he dug in, the reasons had nothing to do with how people learn. They came down to incentives, institutions and fear. Three things he said that I haven’t stopped thinking about:
* “Visual learners” are a myth. The research doesn’t support learning styles, however true they feel.
* The classroom is a budget decision. One-on-one tutoring is the best way to learn, which is why Oxford and Cambridge ran on tutorials for centuries. We crammed 20 or 600 students into a room because tutors cost too much. If AI can get close to a good tutor, cost stops being the excuse. What’s left is fear of change.
* Schools sell a signal. You can barely measure a difference in what students learn at the 10th-ranked school versus the 100th. What the top schools sell is the signal. David pointed to research showing a top-20 MBA brings big lifetime income gains, while an MBA from a school ranked around 50 can be negative ROI once you count the years out of the workforce.
Which put us right back in my world. If Harvard is the Harry Winston of degrees, a lot of schools further down the list are selling a commodity at a luxury price. That’s the same bind the diamond industry is in right now.
Winners live longer
David doesn’t think chasing status is anything to be ashamed of, even if his morals wish otherwise. He cited a study of Oscar winners and nominees. Both groups are elite actors, and they’re paid about the same. The winners lived longer. (He noted the study has since been revised, so hold the details loosely.) The broader pattern, that higher status goes with longer life even after controlling for income, keeps turning up.
It reminded me of the sales trainer who was the Yoda of my family’s business. His line: when you look good, you feel good, and when you feel good, you live better. It sounds like a sales pitch. There may be more to it than that.
Vision, signal, terror
Then we got into what founding a company does to your head. David spent most of his life getting very good at earning praise: grades, parents, bosses. Then he started a company, and nearly everyone told him the idea was bad. The trap is reshaping the idea until people like it, because that’s how you end up with a bad idea. The best ideas sound impossible. If they didn’t, someone would already have built them. Fifteen years in, he’s still training himself to hear “impossible” and think “opportunity.”
His wife Sarah, a founder herself and a student of the Stoics, noticed he was living through every emotional state an entrepreneur cycles through: the vision, the market’s verdict, and the pure terror. Her question was simple. Why relive all of it when tomorrow brings a fresh batch? He used to spend two hours every night on the phone with his executives, going back over the day. The useful part, he realized, took about five minutes.
My takeaway: lots of things are easy to understand and nearly impossible to live by.
Rolex is where you start, and where you end up
Then David turned the tables and asked me whether watch people are “Rolex people” or “Patek people.” My answer: a Rolex isn’t a watch. It’s a trophy. You buy one when you get married, make partner, sell your company. Some people wear it for the rest of their lives. Others fall down the rabbit hole and chase something more obscure. The joke among collectors is that once you’re truly deep, you come back to Rolex, because Rolex is actually the best. That U-shaped path is why it’s the most powerful brand in the category. That week I was wearing one my father got for his 21st birthday.
He also asked why jewelry has so few big brands. You can count them on one hand: Tiffany, Cartier, Van Cleef & Arpels, Harry Winston. In the last 40 years, only two global ones have been built, David Yurman and Pandora. My view is that jewelry has been driven by materials and commodity for so long that it skipped the storytelling a brand needs. Stamping your name on something doesn’t make it a brand.
David loves objects differently than I do. Where I fixated on a Swatch SCUBA as a kid in the mid-’90s, his formative object was a suitcase with his initials on it, a gift from his family. He dragged it down the driveway in a tantrum, tore it, and then panicked that it wouldn’t be fixed in time for the trip it was meant for. For David the thrill is the perfect object for the perfect job. That’s how a grown man ends up deep on the tensile strength of extension cords. It’s also how he ended up mortified when he lent his yellow DeWalt drill to a gas-line crew and the owner took one look and said, that’s not our tool. Every tool they own is red Milwaukee. Deere or Cat, Ford or Chevy, Rolex or Patek: we declare our allegiances in color.
Everyone hates the speakerphone guy (including the speakerphone guy)
David runs surveys for fun, and his latest went after a pet peeve: people playing audio out loud on their phones in public. In his results, 81% of people run into it at least once a week, and 38% admit they do it themselves. Most of the offenders find it annoying when other people do it. And when he asked them whether they’d rather spend a four-hour flight next to another speakerphone user, a crying baby, or someone eating a jar of tuna, they picked anything but the speakerphone.
His diagnosis: we’re living in a “get mine” era. It isn’t malice so much as a prisoner’s dilemma, and brands are adapting, swapping “this is good for the world” for “this is good for you.” I didn’t want to end there, and David offered a better way out: enjoy things, enjoy other people’s work, and share it.
Which is more or less what this podcast is for.
David’s three things that deserve more attention
* Aaron Sorkin. In a world where everyone uses AI to write, David thinks a phenomenal writer still wins. Even if you don’t like the work, the craft is exceptional.
* Cotopaxi. Especially its backpacks that open flat like a suitcase. He owns about te…
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit atpresent.substack.com
More episodes from "The Materialist : A Podcast from At Present"



Don't miss an episode of “The Materialist : A Podcast from At Present” and subscribe to it in the GetPodcast app.








