The Cosmic Codex podcast

CRITIQUE: “Children of Memory” by Adrian Tchaikovsky

0:00
18:00
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds

Do you or someone you know need professional tech guidance for your author, coaching, or independent publishing business? If so, check out our sponsor Cloudessy, providing fractional Chief Technology Officer services. Simplify your tech stack, prevent launch failures, and build systems that actually support growth.

https://marketing.cloudessy.com/30-minute-tech-stack-update/

Children of Memory is the weakest entry in Adrian Tchaikovsky’s original Children of Time trilogy.1 Tor published this third volume in the U.K. in 2022 and Orbit did so in the United States the next year.2 The trilogy won the Hugo Award for Best Series in 2023—a win Tchaikovsky has declined to claim because of irregularities in the administration of Hugo nominations that year.3

The Colony

The book’s premise resembles certain elements found in Children of Time.4 The ark ship Enkidu, under Captain Heorest Holt, carries its sleeping cargo to a terraformed world.5 In the first book, the terraforming project went wrong, producing a civilization of spiders. Here it goes wrong, producing a world that can support human life, but just barely. The planet Imir is marginal from the start, with soil chemistry not quite lethal to Earth life, but “wrong enough to have all sorts of long-term impacts.”6 The ocean provides no recourse: “There was also a too-big moon, which had its own moon, making the tides a wild riot. This meant settling anywhere near the sea would be a fatal mistake; so much for maritime aquaculture.”7

Generations later, Holt’s descendants live in the farming town of Landfall, where equipment is failing and harvests are getting worse.8 A militia keeps order on behalf of “the older Landfall families,” resulting in a community ruled by status and force: “The punching around here only goes one way, and that’s down.”9

The fragile ecology the terraformers created is the root of the colony’s decline: “A collapse of the resource web leads to a collapse of infrastructure which leads to the collapse of everything else.”10 Here, “everything else” includes civil society. Landfall’s ruling class needs enemies to maintain order, and when it can’t find real enemies, it invents them. Tchaikovsky captures this stark reality with phrases such as “You defined us by not being them”11 and “…find someone more them than you are, and put the boot in.”12

So far, so good. But Landfall is a dull world filled with dull characters, and while Tchaikovsky is skillful enough to convey that dullness convincingly, he’s unsuccessful in writing an interesting story about an uninteresting place.

Holt is a decent man worn to a nub, the parts of him “that wanted to scream and beat at the walls … locked away for now.”13 Liff, the main character for much of the story,14 is a clever girl15 who doesn’t receive enough opportunities to make her cleverness count. The townsfolk are a mob in waiting, and little else. The novel forces readers to spend far too much time in their company, waiting for an unsatisfying payoff.

It’s not helpful that Tchaikovsky resorts to a plot device that may still make headlines, but which creators have overused in the past quarter-century. Long-time science fiction readers are likely to see it coming, and a twist that the reader anticipates is no longer a twist.

The Corvids

Just as the strongest elements of Tchaikovsky’s excellent Children of Ruin were the octopuses and the Nodan organism,16 here they’re the Corvids and the Interlocutor.

The Corvids are Gethli and Gothi, a pair of crow-like birds traveling with the strangers,17 and they are the most humorous and most unsettling characters in the book. Each Corvid on its own is a clever animal. Together they’re…more. Their species works in bonded pairs, one partner storing and recalling information while the other analyzes and invents.18 Tchaikovsky depicts this partnership as a single mind emerging from the interaction of two entities. The birds trade “a quickfire rattle of ratchety consonants that serve as thoughts from one side of their shared brain to the other”19—as Tchaikovsky puts it, “In the space between each pair, a mind.”20

As with the spiders and octopuses, he knows what he’s talking about. Real corvids have become a major subject of research on animal intelligence, and researchers have documented tool manufacture, caching strategies that take account of which other birds were watching, and apparent planning for the future—abilities that developed independently of the great apes’ and amount to a case of convergent evolution.21 Like many real corvids, those in Children of Memory pair for life. Tchaikovsky turns the pair bond into the species’ seat of cognition.22

What makes the Corvids memorable, though, is how they characterize their own cognition. They insist, cheerfully and at length, that they are not conscious. “We’re a mistake, basically,” one of them explains; “…what we really are is a problem-solving engine.”23 Regarding those who credit them with inner lives, they remark: “They are very keen to convince themselves that we’re aware, but the evidence suggests otherwise.” They also share a disturbing observation: “Don’t tell the Humans, but it’s just the same for them.”24

This is John Searle’s Chinese Room—a system producing outward signs of understanding, while its structure would seem to make this doubtful.25 This doesn’t bother the Corvids. They find the whole question beside the point: “Neither of us need to understand anything. The understanding sits between us.”26 Real neuroscience may indicate otherwise. In 2020, researchers at the University of Tübingen recorded neurons in crows, the activity of which tracked whether a bird reported seeing a faint stimulus—a candidate neural signature of sensory consciousness in a bird.27 This might impress readers, but perhaps not the Corvids.

The Interlocutor

The second strength is Miranda, part of a scout ship crew sent to investigate a signal from Imir. She’s the expedition’s Interlocutor—a Nodan organism, the memory-absorbing parasite from Children of Ruin, now inhabiting a laboratory-grown human body.28

Miranda’s scenes in Landfall carry empathy the colonists lack for one another.29 In a fascinating reversal, the inhuman “monster” from the second novel has become the most humane character in the third.

Sentience

While Tchaikovsky’s major theme in Children of Ruin was intelligence, here it’s sentience, but in a loose sense. As often occurs in science fiction, he conflates sentience (the ability to feel sensations such as pleasure and pain), sapience (the ability to solve complex intellectual problems), and consciousness (subjective experience—the sense of being oneself).30 The second novel asked whether minds with different evolutionary histories could understand one another. Children of Memory asks how anyone—spider, octopus, crow, human, or organism—can know that there is someone home at all.

Tchaikovsky presents this mystery through the Corvids’ bargain-basement philosophy of mind. It’s clear and entertaining, better than most textbook accounts. Gethli tells Gothi that “…we can’t ever really know if we understand or not. It feels as though we do, up until the point that we’re challenged…”31

While the Corvids explain sentience (or its lack), Miranda and her other crewmates explore it. They assume that the signal they came to investigate on Imir is a sign of sentient activity, but later find reason to doubt such an assumption.32

Miranda’s very nature provides an intriguing perspective. A creature that exists as a copy of another creature and remembers being many things cannot take its own continuity for granted. What frightens Miranda is not that she feels diminished, but that she feels entirely herself. This scares her “[b]ecause it means her sense of self is fallible.”33

Using stricter definitions of “sentience,” “sapience,” and “consciousness,” the Corvids as individuals are sentient. In bonded pairs, they’re sapient, but they may not be conscious at all. The Nodan organism is both conscious and sapient, but may not be sentient outside of a host. And humans, as the creators of the terms used to describe our own mental experience, are all three.

The plot device discussed earlier is essential to the climax of the book. Tchaikovsky uses it to examine, on a larger canvas, the same doubts the Corvids have expressed about their own “sentience” (really, consciousness). But to reach this payoff, such as it is, the reader spends most of the novel in a tedious place populated by many tedious people.

Verdict

Children of Memory is a serious novel with fascinating questions about sentience. It deserves a better story and, with a few notable exceptions, better characters.

Recommended for: Readers who finished Children of Ruin wanting more; anyone interested in the philosophy of mind, or in the intelligence of crows.

Not recommended for: Anyone who wants the plot to move as fast as the ideas.



This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.thecosmiccodex.com

More episodes from "The Cosmic Codex"