Nutter Butter

The Cookie Cult indulges in some cookies for breakfast on this week's episode reviewing Cookie Crisp! Is this kids cereal worth the morning sugar rush or is it a bowl full of broken dreams?

In this Labor Day special episode, Claire and Matt head to the country club to try out one of The Broadmoor's chocolate chip cookies! Is this fresh baked treat worthy of cult status or should visitors of the 5-Star resort skip it all together? Listen and find out!

This week Claire and Matt review Lofthouse Sugar Cookies! Do these children's birthday and office Christmas party staples have what it takes to make it into The Cookie Cult? Or do they belong in the trash? Listen to find out!

The Cookie Cult's Claire and Matt are in for an East Coast treat in this week's episode! The cookie in the hot seat is Tate's Bake Shop Chocolate Chip Cookies. See if the Southampton sensation has what it takes to earn a seat at the table of The Cookie Cult!

Take a field trip to the circus with The Cookie Cult! This week Claire and Matt review a nostalgia packed bag of Mother's: The Original Circus Animal Cookies! Will this circus be a magnificent high wire act or a bloody lion mishap of a disaster?

Wake and break, cult members! This week the Cookie Cult reviews Nestle Toll House's Chocolate Chip Lovers break and bake cookies. Find out if this easy to make cookie makes it into the Cookie Cult!

It's The Cookie Cult pod's first ever review of fresh baked cookies! This week Claire and Matt review four of Subway's cookie flavors. Will this first fresh cookie make it into The Cookie Cult?! Listen and find out!

Today on the Cookie Cult we are reviewing Nutter Butter! Will this classic peanut butter sandwich cookie cause us to bust a nut? Or will it leave us feeling unsatisfied? Listen to find out!

Is the Milano: Dark Chocolate Sea Salt cookie too fancy for the Cookie Cult? Or is the seemingly fancy cookie the perfect taste and textural balance for The Cookie Cult's taste buds? The Cookie Cult will be the judge of that!

On today's episode of The Cookie Cult, we review the beloved Famous Amos! Will this famous LA cookie live up to its lofty name?! We'll be the judge of that!