
Welcome back to the Be Still Podcast! This week Brett, MJ and I finally have boom arms, one of which immediately falls off. Then we get into a big one: should churches be singing hymns, modern worship, or a mix of both? We close with a hate comment about what our blanket is made of, which turned into a real conversation about fear, convictions and the internet.
"Be still, and know that I am God." Psalm 46:10
CHAPTERS
0:00 Welcome to episode 6
0:37 The new boom arms
1:04 The boom arm falls off
1:30 Twins
2:06 Should churches sing hymns or modern worship?
3:20 Hymns: rich, but a little stuffy
5:16 MJ's church background
7:14 Modern worship: easier for a newcomer
8:00 When you're not feeling it
9:05 Who is worship really for?
9:53 Modern takes on old hymns
10:53 What will worship look like in heaven?
11:45 Hymns were modern once
13:35 Preference or disagreement?
14:35 So what does Caleb prefer?
15:56 Our "sponsor" and a Christmas album
17:08 God wrote the greatest story
18:13 Christmas hymns everyone knows
19:39 A pop song in a church service
21:04 Psalms, hymns and spiritual songs
22:49 Does the songwriter matter?
24:56 What should kids be singing?
27:29 Philippians 1:15-18
28:30 A 9 a.m. and an 11 a.m. service
29:59 Why we do a hate comment segment
30:54 Hate comment of the day: polyester
32:32 Where do you draw the line?
33:28 Fear and going non-toxic
36:00 Your convictions aren't everyone's
36:41 MJ stole a blanket
37:59 What the blanket is made of
38:27 Would the Bible support 100% cotton?
39:52 Anyone can have a platform now
40:45 Don't die on every hill
41:17 Wrap up
WHAT WE TALKED ABOUT
The boom arms: Brett and MJ don't have to hold their mics anymore. I put the arms up the same day we filmed this, so of course Brett's started falling off about a minute in and I had to crawl over and fix it live.
Hymns: Brett started us off. Hymns are theologically rich and they've stood the test of time, like Amazing Grace, Great Is Thy Faithfulness, Be Thou My Vision and When I Survey the Wondrous Cross. The downside is they can feel a little stuffy, and when your head is down in a hymn book you might not be as fully present in worship.
Modern worship: MJ has been in very charismatic churches and now goes to a church with a hymnal and an organ, so she's seen both. Modern worship can be easier for a newcomer to get into. It can also be very emotionally driven, and if you're not feeling what everyone else is feeling, you can start asking if something is wrong with you.
Hymns were modern once: nobody wrote one in the 1700s and had everyone agree it was perfect. And Scripture itself talks about psalms, hymns and spiritual songs, so there's room for all of it. We'd be belittling God to think there's only one way to worship Him through song.
Does the songwriter matter: what if you deeply disagree with the person who wrote the song? MJ's take is that if the song is true and honoring, it's still an opportunity to worship. I read Philippians 1:15-18, where Paul rejoices that Christ is proclaimed even when the motives are bad. God doesn't need a perfect vessel to do His will.
The hate comment: on one of our ads, someone asked "No chemicals what kind of material?" and someone else replied that it's 100% polyester, which is actually plastic. I replied asking if they require their car not to use polyester, or their local ice cream shop. MJ called me out on being very honest in my replies, which is fair.
Fear and convictions: MJ got on her soap box. If you want to go non-toxic, go for it, it's your house. Just don't do it out of fear, because God is in control, and don't try to scare other people into it. Your convictions are great, but they aren't the reason someone else has to do the same thing.
The blanket: yes, it's polyester. That's what most soft plush blankets are made of. If you want a 100% cotton blanket, go for it. MJ already stole one, and it's in her washing machine.
YOUR TURN
Should churches sing hymns, modern worship, or a mix? And would it change how you feel about a song if you found out who wrote it? Tell us where you land.
HOSTS
Caleb Weidner, founder of Forty-Six Ten
Brett Fleming, sales and partnerships
MJ Fleming, warehouse manager and customer care
ABOUT FORTY-SIX TEN
Forty-Six Ten is a Christian apparel company named after Psalm 46:10. Every order is picked, packed and shipped out of our warehouse in South Jersey, the same place we filmed this episode.
Shop: https://fortysixten.net
Instagram: @fortysixtenco
TikTok: @fortysixten
Be still and know. We'll see you next time.
#BeStillPodcast #ChristianPodcast #ChurchDebate
More episodes from "The Be Still Podcast"



Don't miss an episode of “The Be Still Podcast” and subscribe to it in the GetPodcast app.








