
Sidebar - Close Enough to Count
Statutes & Stethoscopes: Sidebar - Close Enough to Count.
A high fall risk nursing home resident gets up alone because the bed alarm is off. She breaks her hip, has surgery, develops pneumonia and dies eleven days later. Did the nursing home cause her death? The factual chain is only half the question the law asks.
In this Sidebar I explain the difference between cause in fact and proximate cause, Pennsylvania's substantial factor test, and why foreseeability sits at the heart of it. We revisit Palsgraf v. Long Island Railroad, Judge Cardozo's majority and Judge Andrews' famous dissent, walk through the broken arm, dropped stretcher and poorly set fracture example, and cover superseding causes, the eggshell rule and increased risk of harm.
Proximate cause is ultimately a question for the jury. The expert's job is to lay out every link in the chain clearly and honestly, including the weak ones.
This is educational information, not legal advice. Proximate cause rules vary by state, and the attorney on the case can explain how they work in their jurisdiction.
For clinicians who want to do medical-legal work properly, start with the Expert Report Starter Kit: https://nationalexpertacademy.com
Med Legal Pro matches, screens and trains the medical experts attorneys rely on in medical malpractice, personal injury, nursing home and wrongful death litigation: https://medlegalpro.com
Have a topic you want covered? Suggest it here: https://medlegalpro.com/podcast-topics/
Want to be a guest on the show? Apply here: https://medlegalpro.com/podcast-guest/
Hosted by Tracy Liberatore, Esq. (PA, Emeritus).
Produced by APodcastGeek
https://apodcastgeek.com/
More episodes from "Statutes & Stethoscopes | Trial Lessons for Medical Injury Lawyers"



Don't miss an episode of “Statutes & Stethoscopes | Trial Lessons for Medical Injury Lawyers” and subscribe to it in the GetPodcast app.








