
Fourth Amendment expert and Stanford professor Orin Kerr discusses the first court rulings on Flock license plate cameras and why the Fourth Amendment offers judges no easy middle ground.
----
Solar-powered cameras on utility poles, traffic lights, and squad cars now photograph license plates as cars drive by, and police can search the results, sometimes across state lines. In one recent case, an officer in Oklahoma entered the plate of a car with California tags into a national database and pulled up about 50 records of where it had been. A federal court held that it was a search requiring a warrant. Another court ruled that it was not. Does the Constitution have anything to say about a camera network that logs every car that drives by?
In this special episode of Stanford Legal, Stanford Law professor Orin Kerr (MS ’94), who specializes in criminal law and procedure with a focus on the Fourth Amendment and new technologies, shares a lecture on how the law applies to Flock cameras.
Kerr traces how courts have responded to a series of tracking technologies, including a 1980s radio beeper, GPS devices, cell phone location records, and the Google location data at issue in June’s Chatrie ruling. He argues the result leaves courts with two coherent choices, treating Flock cameras as always a search or never one on public roads. The middle ground is just as hard to find. A rule that turns on how many cameras a town has would invite police to stay just under the line, he says, and one that treats combining data from different cameras as a search would be hard to apply. Connecting information used to be considered good police work, Kerr says, but “now we think of that as potentially constitutionally problematic, raising the issue of when does a combination make something a search.”
Links:
- Orin Kerr >>> Stanford Law School page
- How Should Flock Cameras Be Regulated Under the Fourth Amendment? >>> Stanford Law School page
- A Few Thoughts on the Chatrie Oral Argument >>> Stanford Law School page
- The Difficulty of the Search Question: More Thoughts on Chatrie >>> Stanford Law School page
- Stanford’s Orin Kerr on Court’s Decision Requiring Warrant for Google Location Data >>> Stanford Law School page
Connect:
- Episode Transcripts >>> Stanford Legal Podcast Website
- Stanford Legal Podcast >>> LinkedIn Page
- Rich Ford >>> Twitter/X
- Pam Karlan >>> Stanford Law School Page
- Diego Zambrano >>> Stanford Law School Page
- Stanford Law School >>> Twitter/X
- Stanford Lawyer Magazine >>> Twitter/X
Chapters:
(00:00:00) Introduction: A Live Lecture from Orin Kerr
(00:04:00) What Flock Cameras Actually Are
(00:06:16) The Interface, Free-Text Search, and the National Network
(00:09:44) Retention Policies: Software Settings That Can Change Overnight
(00:11:10) Why Police Want the Technology, and Why Others Object
(00:14:11) Policy Debate vs. the Constitutional Question
(00:15:21) From Knotts to Jones: Public Movements and Tracking
(00:18:15) Carpenter and the Short-Term/Long-Term Dodge
(00:21:22) Chatrie: The Supreme Court Turbocharges Fourth Amendment Protection
(00:24:17) Option One: Knotts Survives, and Public Cameras Aren’t Searches
(00:26:31) Option Two: Every Government Camera Query Is a Search
(00:28:12) Why There’s No Middle Ground: No Preexisting “Thing”
(00:29:38) Testing Middle-Ground Rules: Density, Networking, and Network Size
(00:34:26) Q&A: Policing Strategy, Empirical Data, and What a Warrant Would Look Like
(00:37:21) Q&A: License Plates vs. Natural-Language Searches
(00:39:26) Q&A: Can Camera Count Still Matter After Chatrie?
(00:41:11) Q&A: Private Companies, Ring Cameras, and Consent
(00:43:24) Q&A: Pedestrians and Whether License Plates Are Special
(00:44:33) Conclusion
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
More episodes from "Stanford Legal"



Don't miss an episode of “Stanford Legal” and subscribe to it in the GetPodcast app.








