Marshmallow

Couldn't get enough of our 2026 Halloween (ish) double.header? Here's Part 2! Because we can't stay away, we're closing out spooky season with another horror anthology.What do Adrienne Barbeau, Night of the Living Dead, and non-trademarked candy have in common? We've somehow got to fit them all into a party-planning list! Oh, and they may also be congregating in a nondescript town on Halloween night.Join Katie and Tori as they run the gauntlet of 10 segments from some interesting names in horror. There's even a Joe Dante cameo in it for you!

It's Part 1 of our 2026 Halloween-ish double header upload! And could it possibly be... the greatest divorce story ever told?Katie and Tori are packing up to head to the Deer Cheer in Wheelsy, South Carolina. This year's festivities have gotten a bit worm-y though.Suit up for a good ole-fashioned monster hunt. By the end, we guarantee you'll be a card-carrying member of the Grant Grant Appreciation Club.

Picking up your life and moving to a town with a murderous clown is a proper trauma response... right? It has to be when a doctor does it.Katie and Tori are on the road to Kettle Springs. And it's not the destination they're excited about, it's the Frendos they meet along the way.Hop in the car to enjoy some good ole-fashioned generational prejudice, a proper hoedown, and how you can plan one of your own.

Your reservation is ready for Scary Good Time - Season 2!Katie and Tori are back across the pond for a movie that's kept them talking since they saw it back in May. Let's take a mushroom-fueled trip the Bilberry Woods Hotel, where the protagonists are snarky and the vibes are off-putting.Stick around for party planning that's sure to help you thin the veil.

After almost a full year with a varied roster of horror flicks and shenanigans abound, Katie and Tori are closing the chapter on Season 1 of Scary Good Time!Gather 'round the bonfire with all the classic summer camp staples: s'mores, cozy sweatshirts, and murderous doctors! Jury's still out on that last one, but we can guarantee if you haven't seen this 2025 feature yet - you'll want to watch it BEFORE the episode to avoid being spoiled.Bid farewell to summer with us in this season finale episode.

In honor of the late great Sir Sam Neill, Katie and Tori revisit one of his most iconic turns in cosmic horror. On the way, they'll discover so many things! Auto-spawning dobermans, an incredibly sassy protagonist, and a healthy fear of the color blue. Get down with Sutter Cane for a party that'll make you go mad with excitement.

It's summer and you know what that means! Drinking, partying, running people over, getting away with murder... All the staples of a productive Fourth of July holiday.For this festive and celebratory episode (happy birthday to Katie!), she and Tori dive into one of her favorite holiday horror movies. Get your Croaker crown and scepter, we're in for some rough waters and party planning.

Night clubs! Sunglasses at night! Rapid aging! ...excitement?For the first time in Scary Good Time history, we're watching a movie that's completely unknown to Katie and Tori! And boy, are the curtains fluttering and the David Bowies screaming.Join us in 1980s New York City, where we learn to party the sexy vampire way. There may be some rare steak involved.

After some much-needed TLC, Katie and Tori are back from some "best friend counseling on hard mode..." Otherwise known as a viewing of Bone Lake. Will their friendship survive how aggravating some of these characters can be?For that answer and some party shenanigans down at the lake, let's dive in and meet quite possibly Katie and Tori's favorite horror movie villains to date. And yes, you will probably judge them for that.

Have you heard the good word of our lord and savior (and ultimate party reptile) Nicolas Cage?For the first time on the podcast, Katie and Tori cover one of their favorite actors for an animatronic-walloping good time. Meet them in the Super Happy Fun Room as they plan a birthday party Hayesville, Nevada style.