Reiter Than You 9-18-25 Full Show

Bill opened the show by arguing how multiple NFL teams have squandered great quarterbacks, highlighted by the Bengals wasting Joe Burrow. Bill then responds to listener reactions to his argument before diving into Would You Rather, where he decides between eliminating the tush push or the DH in the NL, going back to college as an athlete or band member and eating 100 peppers in a day or never eating a pepper again. National champion and Heisman Trophy winner Tim Tebow joined the show to discuss his message to Texas quarterback Arch Manning and the best college quarterbacks since he graduated. Buy or Sell was next as Bill answered if the Cubs will make a postseason run and if Mike McDaniel will be fired before Billy Napier. The show ended with Bill and Ryan discussing if McDaniel or Tua Tagovailoa are more to blame in Miami.

Bill opened the show by arguing how multiple NFL teams have squandered great quarterbacks, highlighted by the Bengals wasting Joe Burrow. Bill then responds to listener reactions to his argument before diving into Would You Rather, where he decides between eliminating the tush push or the DH in the NL, going back to college as an athlete or band member and eating 100 peppers in a day or never eating a pepper again. National champion and Heisman Trophy winner Tim Tebow joined the show to discuss his message to Texas quarterback Arch Manning and the best college quarterbacks since he graduated. Buy or Sell was next as Bill answered if the Cubs will make a postseason run and if Mike McDaniel will be fired before Billy Napier. The show ended with Bill and Ryan discussing if McDaniel or Tua Tagovailoa are more to blame in Miami.

Bill opened the show by explaining why Clemson head football coach Dabo Swinney is washed up and will never win another national championship as a head coach. Bill and Ryan then drafted the 0-2 NFL teams that they believe in the most to make the playoffs before getting into Start/Bench/Cut, where Bill ranked the quarterbacks that will win their first Super Bowl next and the worst insult to be called. Hour two kicked off with ESPN NFL and college football analyst Sam Acho joining the show to discuss his concern level for Arch Manning and if he believes the Chiefs can still make the playoffs despite starting 0-2. Buy or Sell is next as Bill answered if the Big Ten screwed USC and if Mariners catcher Cal Raleigh is having one of the more impressive seasons we've seen in a long time. The show ended with Bill diving deeper into Arch's struggles and discussed when he believes the Texas quarterback could get back on track.

Bill opened the show by praising Baker Mayfield for leading the Buccaneers to a last-second victory over the Texans and credited him for turning his career around. Bill then reacted to Tom Brady's conflict of interest and discussed whether the Raiders have an unfair advantage. Bill then gives his NFL Week 2 power rankings to close out hour one. 3x Super Bowl champion Devin McCourty joined the show to kick off hour two and discussed his approach defensively when facing inexperienced quarterbacks, the toughest quarterback he ever had to face and if there is a conflict of interest between Tom Brady's Raiders ownership stake and his broadcasting career. Buy or Sell was next as Bill answered if if the Vikings are using J.J. McCarthy's ankle injury as an excuse to bench him for poor play and if the Chargers are Super Bowl contenders. The show concluded with Bill discussing Mike McDaniel's job security and if the Chargers are truly set up to compete for a championship this season.

Bill opened the show by discussing his concern level for the Kansas City Chiefs after their 0-2 start to the season before reacting to the report that Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow will need surgery on his toe, which will knock him out for at least the next three months. Bill also reacted to the poor quarterback play from both Aaron Rodgers and J.J. McCarthy on Sunday before getting into 5 Things You Need To Know from the Week 3 college football slate. The second hour starts with Super Bowl champion Joe Theismann joining the show to discuss how the Commanders could prevent a sophomore slump for Jayden Daniels and his concern level for the Chiefs. Buy or Sell is next as Bill answered if the Bengals should trade for Kirk Cousins and if Notre Dame should still be ranked. The show ends with Bill reacting to the betting odds as to who could be the next UCLA head coach and his frustration with the Bears after their blowout loss to the Lions.

Bill started the show by explaining how the Packers made a statement in their win over the Commanders before crediting Green Bay's defense for their dominant effort. Bill then credits the Packers for developing Jordan Love before discussing if he's concerned about a sophomore slump for Jayden Daniels. Hour two kicked off with former Steelers running back Merril Hoge joining the show to discuss his impressions with Caleb Williams and his concern level with the Chiefs if they fall to 0-2. Buy or Sell was next as Bill answered if Pete Carroll-Jim Harbaugh is the best coaching rivalry in the NFL and if USF should be ranked #1 if they beat Miami. The show ends with Bill naming the Bum of the Week.

Bill opened the show by previewing the Packers-Commanders Thursday night game and explained how this could be the start of the next great quarterback rivalry between Jayden Daniels and Jordan Love. Bill and Ryan then gave their Commanders-Packers predictions before reacting to the latest piece of reporting by Pablo Torre that claims the Clippers minority owner contributed to the scheme to circumvent the salary cap. Would You Rather was next as Bill decides between Caleb Williams or J.J. McCarthy and getting in trouble on or off the field. Hour two kicks off with Super Bowl champion Brady Poppinga joining the show to discuss his biggest takeaways from Week 1 and the biggest threat to the Packers in the NFC North. Buy or Sell was next as Bill answers if the 49ers will go undefeated with Mac Jones at quarterback and if NBA players caring more about stats than winning is concerning. Vegas Mistake's Kevin Todd then joined the show to discuss his best bets of Week 3 before Bill ended the show by discussing which NFL teams could start the season 0-2.

Bill opened the show by explaining how the AFC is more wide open than we expected after Week 1 and named the team that he thinks could take advantage of that the most. Bill then scolded the Associated Press member that submitted an incorrect college football ballot and explained why it's a big deal. Start/Bench/Cut is next as Bill ranked the quarterbacks that impressed him the most in Week 1, the trademarks Bill Belichick and Jordon Hudson should pursue next and the best no-show jobs for Kawhi Leonard that won't get him in trouble. Former NFL tight end Clay Harbor then joined the show to discuss his expectations for Bears quarterback Caleb Williams moving forward, his impressions with Justin Fields and if the Packers are the favorites to win the NFC North. Buy or Sell was next as Bill answered if Aaron Rodgers will last 17 games and if NFL teams putting roofs on their stadiums is a good thing. The show ends with Bill discussing whether the NBA could punish Kawhi Leonard for reportedly demanding no-show jobs.

Bill opened the show by lamenting another disappointing Chicago Bears performance and voiced his concern about what he saw from quarterback Caleb Williams. Bill then praised the Minnesota Vikings and specifically J.J. McCarthy for his gutsy fourth quarter performance. Bill then gives his NFL power rankings heading into Week 2 of the season to end the hour. Dennis Dodd joined the show to breakdown how hot Billy Napier's seat is at Florida and who will win the Big 12. Buy or Sell was next as Bill answered if he would rather have Caleb or Tua Tagovailoa as his quarterback moving forward and if the Steelers would be a Super Bowl contender if they traded for Tyreek Hill. The show ended with Bill and Ryan discussing the biggest outlier performances from Week 1.

Bill opened the show by criticizing the Baltimore Ravens for blowing another big lead and explained why Lamar Jackson is the most to blame for the loss. Bill then discussed his biggest takeaways from Week 1, including Aaron Rodgers impressing against the Jets, the Packers stomping the Lions, the Bengals squeaking by the Browns, the Dolphins awful performance against the Colts and why he's optimistic about Justin Fields. 5 Things You Need To Know: College Football Week 2 was next as Bill reacted to South Florida upsetting Florida, Mississippi State taking down Arizona State and Bill Belichick explaining why he banned Patriots scouts from UNC's practices. Ty Dunne joined Bill to kick off hour two to discuss his expose on Caleb Williams and his biggest Week 1 takeaways before diving into Buy or Sell, where Bill answered if he's worried that the Lions will miss the playoffs and if Josh Allen's fourth quarter performance was more impressive than Justin Herbert's. The show ends with Bill laughing at a Missouri fan passing up an opportunity to win a massive cash prize to insult Kansas.