Real Ghost Chatter podcast

Episode 92: The Smurl Haunting

0:00
17:10
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds

EPISODE DESCRIPTION

In 1973, Jack and Janet Smurl moved into half of a double-block house on Chase Street in West Pittston, Pennsylvania. Jack's parents took the other half. For 13 years both households reported the same things through the same wall: knocking, voices calling in the family's own tones from empty rooms, a faceless black shape that walked through the wall and came out the other side. Three attempted exorcisms failed, and Janet said the reason was simple, that the thing crossed to whichever half the priest was not in. Mary Ann Poll tells the Smurls' account the way they told it, gives the doubters their full say, and follows the story to the prayers the family said ended it.

EPISODE NOTES

● Built on the shared wall. Jack's mother Mary heard the knocking on her side, heard a man and a woman fighting on a night Jack and Janet were not in the room, and watched the faceless shape come out her side after Janet watched it walk into the wall.

● Phenomena covered: objects vanishing and returning, stains rising through fresh paint, knocking from inside a switched-off television, family voices calling from empty rooms, screams and pig grunts and hoofbeats, cold rooms, an unplugged radio at full volume, the stench of smoke and rotten meat, the 75-pound German shepherd slammed into a wall, Dawn attacked in the shower at 17, Shannon thrown down a flight of stairs at 8, the bed shaking, Janet pinned to the mattress, and Jack dragged off his knees while praying the rosary.

● Their neighbor Debbie Watson reported screams from the house when no one was inside it, and scratching at an upstairs window screen.

● The skeptical case is given in full: Paul Kurtz of CSICOP called it a hoax and pointed to the mine shafts under the street, the sewer odor, and the book deal that followed within months. Jack's 1983 brain surgery was raised publicly, and the family declined psychiatric testing.

● The Church stayed in the middle. Chancellor Gerald Mullally said they believed the family but did not know what it was, and a diocesan priest spent two nights in the house in October 1986 with nothing happening.

● Four days before Halloween 1986 the Smurls said the demons were gone, credited to their own parish and their own prayers rather than the three failed exorcisms. They left Chase Street in 1988, and later residents on both sides reported nothing. Jack died in 2017, Janet in 2026. Approximately 2,414 spoken words.

SCRIPTURE

Psalm 91:1, 2, 5 (NIV) — 'Whoever dwells in the shelter of the Most High will rest in the shadow of the Almighty. I will say of the Lord, he is my refuge and my fortress, my God, in whom I trust. You will not fear the terror of night, nor the arrow that flies by day.'

SOURCES

● Steve Corbett, Wilkes-Barre Times Leader, August 19, 1986

● Associated Press and United Press International wire coverage, August 1986

● Robert Curran, The Tribune (Scranton), October 27, 1986

● Paul Kurtz, 'A Case Study of the West Pittston Haunted House,' The Skeptical Inquirer, Winter 1987

● Robert Curran with the Smurls and Ed and Lorraine Warren, The Haunted: One Family's Nightmare (St. Martin's Press, 1988)


More episodes from "Real Ghost Chatter"