Picking Justice podcast

Gary Dordick – Why Your Ideal Juror Might Sink Your Case (Rewind)

11/16/2026
0:00
1:06:22
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds

The jurors who look perfect on paper can sink a case, while the ones who seem dangerous can help carry it. Gary Dordick, founder of Dordick Law Corporation with 10-figure verdicts to his name, has learned to look past those first impressions. He tells hosts Harry Plotkin and Dan Kramer about a trial where the defendant cried during jury selection and most of the panel admitted they felt sorry for her. Rather than strike them, Gary kept them, and the one juror he did remove may surprise you. Tune in for the full story, plus how Gary opens the money conversation in voir dire by starting with a line jurors expect to hear from the defense.

Learn More and Connect

☑️ Gary Dordick | LinkedIn | Instagram

☑️ Dordick Law Corporation | LinkedIn | Instagram | TikTok | X | YouTube

☑️ Harry Plotkin | LinkedIn | Facebook | Instagram

☑️ Dan Kramer | LinkedIn

☑️ Kramer Trial Lawyers on LinkedIn | Facebook | YouTube | Instagram

☑️ Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Spotify | YouTube

Produced and Powered by LawPods, a podcast marketing agency for law firms

00:00:00 Meet Gary Dordick

00:03:14 Jury selection in his first trial

00:10:16 Explaining bias to the jury

00:15:00 Drawing out bias on a questionnaire

00:17:28 When a shared background backfires

00:21:21 Motorcyclists and jurors with injuries

00:24:20 The defendant who cried in voir dire

00:29:33 Jurors who say verdicts are too high

00:35:12 Reading 60 questionnaires overnight

00:38:47 More bad jurors than strikes

00:42:10 Why he kept a Marine and a firefighter

00:46:13 The juror he was sure was on his side

00:51:09 Talking money in voir dire

00:57:38 The Gary Dordick Show

01:00:55 Questions for jurors he can't read

More episodes from "Picking Justice"