The Goats of Growth podcast

Why PayReady's All-AI Rollout Failed, and the Human-in-the-Loop Fix That Worked

0:00
46:53
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds

Dustin Schwarz's team replaced PayReady's human concierge outreach with a fully AI solution. It underperformed: skilled people reach fewer residents, but they resolve far more of the conversations they do reach. So PayReady built a hybrid process where automation handles routing and simple conversations, and specialists take escalations and sensitive discussions.

Schwarz is chief customer officer at PayReady, the multifamily SaaS platform behind AI-driven rent collection, resident and payment portals, and CRM tools serving more than three and a half million units. He has spent 15-plus years in multifamily and prop tech, including time at RealPage.

His argument: AI is the worst it will ever be today, but "good enough" is a business judgment, and many companies will accept 85% of a human's effectiveness because the incentives reward cutting cost over serving customers. PayReady is betting on the opposite, a customer-centric 100%. That bet is backed by a chief risk officer, a vendor network that shares regulatory updates, and a view that SaaS built on a feature is dead while SaaS built on partnerships and judgment is not.

One concrete result: after buying Buzz.ai, an AI platform trained on property management behavior, PayReady saw variable margin improve roughly two and a half to three times, and one support agent can now serve about three times as many customers.

WHAT WE COVER

- Why a fully automated concierge replacement underperformed human specialists

- Where humans stay in the loop, and whether that share shrinks over two years

- State and local contact rules, junk-fee scrutiny, and legislative risk

- Why "85% good enough" wins in some companies and what that means for customers

- Build versus buy: acquiring Buzz.ai, and moving support to Intercom

- Hiring for adaptability, creativity and language skill over domain experience

- Where AI still fails: people, judgment and high-stakes analytics

CHAPTERS

00:00 Why this episode is out of order

00:57 Intro

02:21 What PayReady does

04:10 Buying Buzz.ai

06:41 Why the all-AI rollout fell short

09:24 The hybrid process

10:40 Will human-in-the-loop shrink?

12:15 Legislative and regulatory risk

14:30 Staying compliant

17:03 Why feature-based SaaS is dead

18:21 Why 85% is "good enough" for some companies

21:06 Business impact: margin and support

22:08 Build versus buy

27:05 Hiring for adaptability over domain experience

34:58 Where AI still fails

39:19 Rapid Fire Five

Connect with Dustin Schwarz on LinkedIn, or learn more about PayReady at payready.com.

This episode is sponsored by Common Room (https://www.commonroom.io/?utm_source=goat-podcast&utm_medium=partner), the AI GTM Intelligence Platform trusted by teams like Okta, Anthropic, and Fireworks AI.

Subscribe to The Goats of Growth on YouTube, Apple Podcasts and Spotify, and leave a rating or review so more go-to-market leaders can find the show.

More episodes from "The Goats of Growth"