Not Bad Dan Not Bad Stories podcast

The Two Types of Trouble

0:00
10:42
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds

Hello reader, please like, comment, and share if you enjoy this, it really helps me out!

There are two kinds of trouble you can get into as a child, they are very different, but the outcomes and consequences are the same. The first type of trouble is ‘crime adjacent trouble’. These are the ‘kids meal’ equivalent of adult crimes. Sort of cute, miniature versions of murder, arson, human trafficking, ect. Found huffing magic markers behind the school? Simple possession. Stealing Pokemon Cards? Grand larceny. Farting really loud on purpose? Usage of weapons of mass destruction. Laughing at said fart? Aiding and abetting a known terrorist.

These sorts of infractions are dealt with harshly. Authority figures have the framework of their severity because of their adult crime equivalents and know what will happen if the behavior persists. They dole out detentions and suspensions to the children who commit them, and either the little criminals buckle under the weight of their sentences, or take them with the steely eyed indifference of a hardened criminal. “1 week no recess? How about you make it two? I’ve got to work on my drawing of what I assume boobs look like.”

The second type of trouble is ‘Please, for the love of god, stop doing that’ trouble. This is where we trek into a new frontier of punishments which do not have adult equivalents, and are at the discretion of the authority figure in charge. Type 2 trouble arises when you do something which does not technically break any rules, but regardless makes teachers uncomfortable. This was the sort of trouble I got into, which was really tough because, although I was 9 years old, I could litigate and argue at the level of a conservative podcaster. One time, I was thrown out of class when the teacher was trying to describe whether words had a positive or negative connotation.

“The word ‘hurt’ has a negative connotation.” She would say, bracing herself for my inevitable interjections.”

“Oh really, what if you ‘hurt’ Osama Bin Laden? Would that be bad Ms. Prock? Last I checked he destroyed the empire state building and the pentagon, a shape which I have yet to learn.”

I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again, no one wanted endless war in the middle east more than 3rd graders.

So I would do strange, abrasive things, get in trouble, and then argue about what specific rule I was breaking. I was often met with the phrase “because I said so” to which I would respond “But why, what thought process led you to have such a negative view on me speaking in a southern accent when I answer questions? I swear I’m not doing this just because I heard one on TV for the first time yesterday, this is who I am, and nobody talks to Texas Donny like this!”

In elementary school I had a far worse relationship with my teachers than my type 1 compatriots. They were problem children, sure, but they had understandable problems. Their actions followed a line of logic. If you want to do well on a test, but you don’t want to study, you cheat. It makes perfect sense. It’s the kind of critical thinking a teacher can appreciate. It’s also the sort of thing an authority figure feels good about correcting. When you are given the power to punish, you often fantasize of wielding the flaming sword of justice with noble discernment. You do not often fantasize about telling a young boy to stop chirping before answering questions.

Leading into middle school, that dynamic began to shift slightly. The type 1 kids, who stayed on the path of crime adjacent activity, became less benign. Scuffles became fights with blood and broken teeth, stealing markers turned into smoking weed, and being late to class morphed into competitive knife fighting. Meanwhile, while my strange behavior was still punished, I think I had broken the spirits of my teachers, who had bigger fish to fry now that my type 1 compatriots had a thirst for blood.

Nevertheless, type 1s and type 2s are always lumped together. I got sent to detention, they got sent to special ed, which I always thought was interesting. Special education was supposed to be a place where students with learning disabilities and emotional problems got sorted out, but it was populated by a bunch of kids who just discovered weed too early.

I knew a kid named Kyle White in middle school, who played football and went to special ed, a combo that was shockingly common. Kyle did not have a learning disability, at least not one you could ever accurately diagnose through the haze of marajuana that was pumping through his bloodstream at all times. It is certainly plausible that he was using weed to medicate an underlying learning disability, and if that was the case, Kyle was one of the most afflicted children who has ever lived. The amount of medication he had to take surpassed an entire terminal cancer ward combined. He took medication before school, after school, during school, during class.

Kyle famously made a contraption fashioned out of a paper towel roll stuffed with different scented materials. He would take a hit from a pipe in class, then exhale it through the contraption. That way, instead of a teacher smelling pungent weed smoke and immediately sending him to the principal, a teacher would smell pungent weed smoke mixed with dryer sheets, and then send him to the principal. He would smile, laugh, say “you got me” and simply half walk half float to the principals office.

There has never been a movie, tv show, or rap song that made me want to smoke weed as a teenager more than Kyle. I didn’t care that weed made food better, I was already eating enough of it at the time according to my pants size that called me “husky” and my classmates who called me “fat ass”. I didn’t care that it made sex better. That’s like if you told me now “you need to try this wild berry, It makes yacht racing so much more enjoyable!” You can’t enhance an experience you’re not having. But watching Kyle, carefree, sauntering to the principals office racked me with jealousy.

I was always so nervous when I got sent to the principals, from elementary to middle school. But, much like a high paid athlete, the pressure elicited performances out of me that I never could have hoped to achieve without the heightened anxiety. You see, I was a master of getting out of trouble once I was already in it. I had a preternatural ability to tell an authority figure exactly what they wanted to hear once cornered. The trick was to give them everything they wanted, then give them more. Make them think their authority had such power that you were in literal physical anguish at the prospect of disappointing them. Sometimes I would even accent my self-admonishment by hitting my head with a flat palm over and over again until the principal would be forced to say “no no, stop that, don’t feel that bad.”

That’s when I knew I had him. My pupils would dilate looking down the long stretching mile I was going to take once they had given me my precious inch. I’d leave the principal’s office, not only not being given a slap on the wrist, but with phone calls to my parents telling them ‘ease off him, he’s a good kid.’

Kyle was not as good at this little trick. He was charming, but he lacked the ability to self flagellate. He had “confidence” and “a sense of identity” and probably a myriad of other traits that were holding him back. We still found ourselves in trouble together fairly often, and we would chat quietly in detention when Officer Gammel (he used to be a police officer but he kept the title) wasn’t paying attention.

“I tried blowing up a bunch of soda bottles with M80s on school property, what did you do?” Kyle would ask, like I was a cell mate on my first day in prison.

“I tried blowing up my homework assignment with my mind.” I would reply sheepishly, feeling as though my crime wasn’t as cool or exciting as Kyle’s. He never made me feel judged though. There were certain “bad” kids who had a sense of inclusion far beyond their “good” counterparts. I remember Jack Bowdich, a kid …



This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit dandonohue.substack.com/subscribe

More episodes from "Not Bad Dan Not Bad Stories"