
The Polar Express stands as a landmark in animation history – the very first full-length computer motion capture film, earning a place in the Guinness Book of World Records alongside other Tom Hanks pioneering projects like Toy Story. Twenty years since its release, hosts Nathan and Katy analyze whether this Christmas classic holds up or falls into the uncanny valley.
Katy shares her deep personal connection to the story, explaining how both the original book and film bring tears to her eyes with the iconic line "the bell still rings for all those who still believe." Her family tradition of watching it and singing along to memorable songs like "Hot Chocolate" highlights why this film remains culturally significant despite its technical shortcomings.
Nathan takes the critical perspective, pointing out the occasionally unsettling animation – from the staring little girl to the creepy puppet sequence and questionable hobo ghost character. Both hosts agree these elements seem unnecessarily frightening for a children's Christmas film. Yet they unanimously praise Josh Groban's emotional song "Believe" as capturing the film's magical essence.
The conversation explores how The Polar Express transcended cinema to become embedded in American Christmas culture, with trains across the country transformed into real-world Polar Express experiences complete with hot chocolate, cookies, and conductors punching golden tickets. This cultural phenomenon demonstrates why, despite its flaws, the film earns high marks as a Christmas classic – Katy awards it 5/5 stars for Christmas spirit while Nathan gives 4/5, with slightly lower overall ratings acknowledging the dated animation.
Ready to revisit this holiday staple or experience it for the first time? Listen now and decide for yourself if you still hear the bell ringing!
More episodes from "The Couch Critic"
Don't miss an episode of “The Couch Critic” and subscribe to it in the GetPodcast app.