MTG Commander Smiths Podcast podcast

šŸ’°šŸ’ø Breaking Down the Secret Scare Superdrop šŸ‘» | What’s Worth It? šŸ’øšŸ’° - #394

0:00
1:59:46
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds

Episode 394:Ā 

šŸŽ™ļøĀ This Week on the CommanderSmiths Podcast!Ā šŸŽ™ļø

We’re diving into the spooky side of Magic this week with a full breakdown of the Secret Scare Superdrop šŸ‘»šŸ•·ļø From creepy new art, to wild crossovers (Jaws, Iron Maiden, The Office mashups, and more), to value adds like the rainbow foil Cryptic Command bonus — we’re covering it all.

We’ll talk about what excites us, what feels a little off, and what we’d like to see in future ā€œscaryā€ drops. Plus… is this drop actually worth it? We’ll crunch numbers, run the Break Points (BP) for each drop, and help you figure out whether it’s a buy, a skip, or somewhere in between.

šŸ”— Links:

šŸ’ø Financial Breakdown (Before Fees & Shipping):

šŸ’ø Financial Breakdown (Before Fees & Shipping):

Artist Series: Kieran Yanner ✨ Foil: $75 (BP 2) – Grade: A- šŸ”„ Non-Foil: $60 (BP 2) – Grade: A-

Jaws: Terror of Amity Island ✨ Foil: $125 (BP 3) – Grade: B+ šŸ”„ Non-Foil: $90 (BP 3) – Grade: B+

The Office: Dwight’s Destiny ✨ Foil: $135 (BP 2) – Grade: A- šŸ”„ Non-Foil: $100 (BP 2) – Grade: A-

Dreaming Darkly ✨ Foil: $70 (BP 5) – Grade: D šŸ”„ Non-Foil: $50 (BP 5) – Grade: D

Iron Maiden: Album Art ✨ Foil: $80 (BP 3) – Grade: C- šŸ”„ Non-Foil: $60 (BP 3) – Grade: C-

Iron Maiden: Eddie Unchained ✨ Foil: $190 (BP 2) – Grade: A+ šŸ”„ Non-Foil: $140 (BP 2) – Grade: A+

Trick or Treat ✨ Foil: $70 (BP 4) – Grade: D+ šŸ”„ Non-Foil: $50 (BP 4) – Grade: D+

Furby: Doo-Ay Noo-Lah 🌌 Galaxy Foil: $125 (BP 3) – Grade: B+ ✨ Foil: $72 (BP 4) – Grade: C+ šŸ”„ Non-Foil: $49 (BP 5) – Grade: C+

Furby: The Gathering 🌌 Galaxy Foil: $110 (BP 4) – Grade: B ✨ Foil: $65 (BP 4) – Grade: C+ šŸ”„ Non-Foil: $50 (BP 5) – Grade: C+

Furby: Oddbodies 🌌 Galaxy Foil: $135 (BP 3) – Grade: B+ ✨ Foil: $80 (BP 3) – Grade: B šŸ”„ Non-Foil: $60 (BP 3) – Grade: B

What’s a Break Point (BP)? Break Point (BP) shows how many drops you need to buy to basically get one ā€œfreeā€ — because let’s be honest, we all want one to keep for the collection.

šŸ‘‰ How it works:

  1. Add up the lowest Foil & Non-Foil singles values.

  2. Subtract drop cost, shipping, and fees = Net Profit.

  3. Divide that profit by the cost of one drop to find the BP.

Example:

  • If a drop costs $40 and has a Net Profit of $80, buying 2 covers the cost of one (BP 2).

  • If the Net Profit is $55, you’d need 4 drops to break even (BP 4).

šŸ’” Pro Tip: Prices usually dip right after shipping, but many recover (or even climb) 10–16 months later. Patience can pay off!

Ā 

🚨Live Cast Here🚨

https://youtube.com/live/myqLx_2JKLg

Ā 

šŸ’øĀ Support the CommanderSmiths!

šŸ”„Ā Join our PatreonĀ for exclusive perks:Ā Patreon šŸ›ļøĀ Grab merch & Kill Him Tokens:Ā Adam’s eBay Store šŸ’°Ā Donate Live:Ā Streamlabs

šŸŽ‰Ā A FREE way to support us?Ā Subscribe & like the video! šŸ‘‰Ā Subscribe Here

Ā 

šŸ”„Ā Recent Videos from the CommanderSmithsĀ šŸ”„

🤫 MAGIC PASSWORD: A MTG Trivia Game 🤫 https://youtu.be/PqpLA7BvZ_c

šŸ‰Ā Elder Dragon 'Not-So-Highlander'Ā šŸ‰ https://youtu.be/Q9SpjVOY4ag

šŸ’¬Ā Got Questions?

šŸ“§ Email us atĀ [email protected]Ā forĀ Stump the Smith SavantĀ submissions, questions, or just to chat!

Don't miss out—subscribe and become part of the CommanderSmiths family today!Ā šŸŽ™ļø

Come for the finance... stay for the chaos! #MTG #Commander #SecretLair #CommanderDeck #MagicTheGathering #EDH

More episodes from "MTG Commander Smiths Podcast"