
Why Characters Who Make Bad Decisions Are Often Better Characters
Ever found yourself shouting at a fictional character because they're about to do something spectacularly stupid? We've all been there. But why do some terrible decisions make characters more compelling, while others leave us wondering what on earth the writer was thinking?
Struggling with a story problem of your own? My Story SOS service offers a focused, one-to-one coaching session where we spend an hour untangling one specific problem with your novel, whether that's character motivation, a plot that's gone off the rails, or something that simply isn't working.
Find out more or book a session: https://www.thebookcoach.co/story-sos
In this episode of Master Fiction Writing, I'm exploring why bad decisions can be brilliant for character development, provided they make sense for the person making them.
We'll look at characters including Jane Austen's Emma Woodhouse, Boromir from The Lord of the Rings, and Walter White from Breaking Bad, and examine how their fears, beliefs, desires and personal blind spots influence their choices.
I'll also introduce Helen, a fictional theatre director whose determination to protect her company leads her into an increasingly disastrous series of decisions.
The important distinction? Readers don't have to agree with a character's decisions. They just have to understand why that character would make them at that particular point in the story.
If you're wondering whether a character's questionable choices are helping or hurting your novel, try these five questions:
Does the decision make sense for this character at this point in the story? Consider what they know, believe, want and fear.
Why does the character believe this is the right choice? Even if the reader can see they're mistaken.
What would making the sensible decision cost them? What makes the alternative emotionally difficult?
Have I established enough for the reader to understand their reasoning? The explanation needs to exist on the page, not just in your head.
What happens because of the decision? Does it create meaningful consequences that influence what happens next?
Remember, a character making a bad decision isn't necessarily a problem. A character making a decision purely because the writer needs something to happen probably is.
Find out more about my book-coaching services: https://www.thebookcoach.co
If you enjoy Master Fiction Writing, please follow the podcast and share it with another writer who might find it useful.
The Bad Decision Test
More episodes from "Master Fiction Writing"



Don't miss an episode of “Master Fiction Writing” and subscribe to it in the GetPodcast app.








