Management Muse podcast

Why Delegating Tasks is Ruining Your Team (and How To Delegate Decisions Instead) with Samantha C. Prestidge [#135]

11/17/2026
0:00
42:45
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds

If delegating tasks actually freed up your time, you wouldn’t still be answering 40 questions a day from your direct reports.

Where most leaders feel they have a capacity problem, what they actually have is a decision bottleneck. Handing off task checklists without handing off decision-making authority doesn’t build an autonomous team, it trains capable people into helplessness, second-guessing, and pinging you for permission on everything.

In this episode, Cindi Baldi sits down with Samantha C. Prestidge, founder of Auxo Business Services and host of Can We Not? Business is Hard Enough podcast, to explain how to delegate in a way that actually frees up executive capacity. Samantha explains what you need to get clear on before hiring help, how to give someone a result to own, and how to assign the right size response to delegation mistakes.

Whether you’re fielding the same questions every week or wondering how much authority you really have, you’ll come away knowing how to clarify who makes the call and when it’s worth stepping in.

What you’ll learn about delegation, decision authority, and managing performance:

  • Why does delegating tasks create bottlenecks? How task-based delegation accidentally encourages micromanagement and team dependence.
  • What should you delegate in the first place? Use Samantha’s Map It, Keep It, Delegate It framework to identify what the business needs, where your time matters most, and what someone else can own. Some work can stop altogether.
  • How can you tell whether an employee underperformed or the brief was unclear? Compare the result with the instructions they actually received. Could a capable person have interpreted the assignment the same way?
  • How do you tell a high standard from a personal preference? Before asking for a revision, explain what would happen to the client, the project, or the business if the work went out as-is.
  • How much oversight should you add after a mistake? Use Samantha’s “blast radius” test. An invoice you can quickly void and an error in figures you’re presenting to the board warrant different safeguards.
  • What to do when your boss second-guesses your decisions. State the goal as you understand it, propose a direction, and get feedback early enough to use it.

Watch This Episode on YouTube: https://youtu.be/-29cvAO23Mg

About Samantha C. Prestidge:

Samantha C. Prestidge is the founder of Auxo Business Services, a U.S.-based virtual assistant and business support company built around a simple idea: talented business owners shouldn’t spend their best time buried in busywork. She helps founders and leaders decide what work is actually worth doing, what is worth their time, and what should be simplified, delegated, or handed to the right support person. Through smarter delegation, practical team strategy, and high-quality support, Auxo helps businesses create more capacity without making business more complicated.

Samantha’s Resources:

The Uncertainty Playbook: 14 Strategies for Work Success in a Chaotic World:

→ Get your copy here. 

Get Science-Backed Insights and Exclusive Perks Straight to Your Inbox:

→ Sign up for our newsletter and get a FREE chapter of The Uncertainty Playbook.

Want to Go Deeper? Check Out Our Recommended Reading:

  • Blunden, Hayley, and Mary Steffel. “Research: How to Delegate Decision-Making Strategically.” Harvard Business Review, Sept. 10, 2024. Read the article.
  • Marquet, L. David. Turn the Ship Around! A True Story of Turning Followers into Leaders. Portfolio, May 2013. Get the book.

Join Our Community & Follow Us: 

- Youtube Channel 

- LinkedIn

- Instagram

-Facebook

-TikTok

- Website

More episodes from "Management Muse"