Liberating Motherhood podcast

S4 Ep7: Why Therapy So Often Causes Harm: Diana Fox Tilson

0:00
51:50
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds

“Therapists can only go as deep with their clients as they’ve gone with themselves.” — Diana Fox Tilson

Why does therapy so often replicate and intensify the harm people experience in their exploitative relationships? Therapy, in theory, is a powerful tool for healing and personal change. But like any medical intervention, it poses risks and side effects. 

Therapy definitionally occurs behind closed doors, which raises the specter of exploitation and harm, even among therapists who truly do mean well. In most therapy sessions, only two people get to evaluate how things went—one of whom can be heavily influenced by the therapist, and the other of whom has a strong interest in viewing their own work favorably. 

In this podcast episode, I talk to therapist Diana Fox Tilson about why therapy so often causes harm, what we can do to find better therapy, and how to know if your therapy sessions are actually working. Some of the topics we cover include: 

  • Why therapy often goes so wrong, and how people who are genuinely good people can still do harm.

  • Zawn’s experience with a bad therapist. 

  • The lack of accountability in private practice, especially with the most vulnerable clients. 

  • Defensiveness among therapists. 

  • The normalization of oppressive scripts in therapy. 

  • The unique dangers of couples counseling. 

  • Differences in how men and women are treated in therapy, and how therapy can subtly reinforce gender norms. 

  • The professional and financial incentives for therapists to not challenge their clients. 

  • How to tell if therapy is working. 

  • How therapists can end up exploiting their clients, whether or not they intend to. 

  • Red flags in therapy. 

  • Why good therapists admit to mistakes. 

About Diana Fox Tilson

Diana Fox Tilson, LICSW, is a psychotherapist in private practice and writes Other Interests on Substack.

More episodes from "Liberating Motherhood"