
Is America one giant cult? That's the question I put to journalist Jane Borden, author of Cults Like Us: Why Doomsday Thinking Drives America. Jane fell into this topic while reporting on cults for Vanity Fair, when she started seeing the same dynamics in American culture, pop culture and politics. Her conclusion: America was founded by groups that look a lot like cults. The Puritans and Pilgrims were high-control doomsday groups, and their ideas never went away. They just went secular.
We dig into the "chosen people" mindset and why it always comes paired with feeling persecuted, why doomsday thinking leaves no room for democracy, and what evolution tells us about us-versus-them thinking (spoiler: our real superpower is cooperation). Jane explains the grace-nature divide, why some people actually want Armageddon, and why conspiracy theories "aren't always wrong, they're just always pointing at the wrong people."
Then it gets wild. The American Monomyth hiding in every Western, superhero and disaster movie. The UFO doomsday cult that gave us the term "cognitive dissonance." John Humphrey Noyes, who believed Jesus was made of electricity and founded the community that became the Oneida silverware company, and the abuse behind that history that rarely gets told. We talk eugenics, pronatalism, and why powerful men want to replicate themselves.
Jane closes with something I didn't expect: she doesn't believe evil exists. She believes in desperation, vulnerability and bad choices, and that fear dissolves through conversation with the very people we fear. This one gave me hope.
KEY TOPICS
- How the Puritans and Pilgrims shaped American culture
- Chosen people, chosen nation, and persecution as two sides of one coin
- Why cults and doomsday thinking are "the death of democracy"
- Us vs. them, evolution, and cooperation as our secret to success
- The grace-nature divide and runaway extraction
- Why some people want Armageddon
- Conspiracy theories: Mankind United, the New World Order, and the kernel of truth
- Scapegoats and the grievance narrative
- The American Monomyth and the Book of Revelation
- Normative dissonance vs. cognitive dissonance (and the Seekers)
- Perfectionism, the Social Gospel, and the Civil War as a doomsday project
- John Humphrey Noyes and the Oneida Community
- Eugenics, Buck v. Bell and 67,000 forced sterilizations
- Income inequality as the crisis fueling cult-like thinking
- Why Jane doesn't believe evil exists
FIND JANE BORDEN
- Book: Cults Like Us, available everywhere.
WORK WITH ME
I'm a podcast and brand strategist. If you want to use your voice as a force for good and a podcast is your platform, or you already have one that isn't doing what you want, book a free clarity call at https://AllisonHare.com/freecall
RESOURCES (U.S.)
- RAINN National Sexual Assault Hotline: 800-656-HOPE (4673), hotline.rainn.org
- Childhelp National Child Abuse Hotline: 1-800-422-4453
- Outside the U.S., contact your local crisis services.
Opinions expressed by guests are their own.
Be sure to rate, review, and follow this podcast on your player and also, connect with me IRL for more goodness and life-changing stuff.
- Schedule a FREE podcast clarity call with me - Your future audience is out there. Talk to them!
- Sign up for the free weekly email
- AllisonHare.com
- Follow me on Instagram, LinkedIn, Facebook, and YouTube.
- DOWNLOAD the free podcast equipment guide- No guesswork, no google rabbit holes, start recording today
- Reb3l Dance Fitness - Try it at home! Free month with this link.
- Feedback and Contact:: [email protected]
More episodes from "Culture Changers with Allison Hare"



Don't miss an episode of “Culture Changers with Allison Hare” and subscribe to it in the GetPodcast app.








