Keeping It Young podcast

Overcoming Lies Part 4

0:00
24:03
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds

Gentle parenting sounds kind, and the word "gentle" is even in the Bible. So why do so many Christian families find their kids getting harder to live with, not easier? In Part 4 of the Overcoming Lies series, Dave and Bethlie turn to parenting and take on one of the most popular ideas in Christian family life today: that gentle parenting works. They explain why a method that ignores the sin nature can't produce obedience, why obedience often has to come before understanding, and why children who are never trained struggle to honor their parents as adults. They also answer a real counseling question: what do you do when one spouse wants gentle parenting and the other doesn't? If you're raising children and want a biblical way forward, or know of someone who does, this is the episdoe to listen to.

Gentle Parenting Sounds Good. Does It Work?

Few parenting ideas have spread as fast as gentle parenting. It promises calmer homes, closer relationships, and children who behave because they feel understood. Plenty of Christian parents have picked it up, partly because of the word itself. Gentleness is a fruit of the Spirit, and Jesus described Himself as meek and lowly.

In this episode, Dave and Bethlie start a short run of episodes on lies about parenting. The first one is the big one: gentle parenting works. Their answer, drawn from Scripture and decades of raising five children, is that it doesn't, and they explain why.

Where Gentle Parenting Comes From

Dave traces part of gentle parenting back to deeper cultural assumptions: that people are simply more evolved animals, and that each generation is more enlightened than the last. Bethlie adds the humanistic piece, the belief that people left to themselves will get better, and that children will lead us well if we just follow their cues.

Why Gentle Parenting Fails

It ignores the sin nature

Gentle parenting assumes children are basically good and only need to be understood. The Bible teaches that every one of us has a sin nature and needs rescue through the death, burial, and resurrection of Jesus Christ. In parenting, God's Word gives a way to train that nature toward obedience, self-control, and self-denial. A method that skips the sin nature ends up affirming tantrums, rudeness, and what the culture calls "big emotions" instead of correcting them.

It replaces biblical training

Correcting, limiting, and disciplining a child are all set aside in favor of explanation. Dave notes that a child who never learns to obey can't develop self-control, and the result is a child who is out of control. The Youngs are concerned that labels and medication are sometimes used to get compliance that training was meant to produce. In their view, if the heart is never changed and obedience is never taught, the child is left to struggle for years.

It produces adults who can't handle authority

Dave and Bethlie point to college students shocked that a professor expects work on time, and young employees surprised that a boss expects them to show up. Parents who start gentle parenting with toddlers often realize by ages six to nine that they have a mess on their hands, and by then it's much harder to undo.

Putting "Gentle" in Biblical Perspective

Bethlie understands why many young Christian couples are drawn in. Some grew up in very strict homes and don't want to repeat that. But gentleness in how we deliver direction is different from a method that removes direction. The same Bible that calls us to be gentle also tells parents to train up a child, warns that a child left to himself brings his mother to shame, and commands children to obey their parents. As Bethlie puts it, children can't obey what isn't directed to them.

Obedience Can Come Before Understanding

One common excuse for not training is, "She just doesn't understand why." Bethlie's answer is a toothbrush. Toddlers brush their teeth long before they understand cavities. They may repeat your explanation about germs, but they don't really get it. They obey anyway, and it does them good. Adults are often the same with God: we take a step of obedience before we see why.

She also cautions parents against deciding that one particular child simply can't be trained. Every child can be trained.

Training Leads to Honor

Dave walks through God's order for the family: a committed marriage, children born into that home, and parents who train them to obey. Children are told to obey their parents in the Lord, and then to honor their father and mother, the first commandment with promise. Honor grows out of obedience. When children learn self-control and parents move into discipling them, a warm, close relationship follows. When everything centers on the child's feelings, many grow into adults who look down on their parents and want little to do with them.

When Husband and Wife Disagree

The Youngs have recently counseled couples where one spouse wants gentle parenting and the other is firmly against it. Sometimes it's the mom, sometimes the dad. Dave's advice:

■      Open the Bible together and get godly counsel.

■      Go to family camps and conferences, and read good books. He recommends Shepherding a Child's Heart by Tedd Tripp and James Dobson's writing on raising children, while reminding listeners that no author is the inspired Word of God.

■      Talk a lot, pray a lot, and study a lot until you're on the same page.

■      Dads, don't back away from the hard work of training sons and daughters.

Dave and Bethlie say plainly that their children weren't perfect, but staying with biblical methods made the child-raising years glorious, and they remain close to all five of their kids today.

Raising Children Who Can Handle Life

Bethlie closes with a question for parents: do you want children who can cope with life and grow spiritually mature? An entitled child can't be spiritually mature. Life as an adult is hard, and children who were trained to obey, respect authority, and live for others go into the world far better equipped, and bring their parents far more joy.

More episodes from "Keeping It Young"