Iyun Lemachshava English podcast

Reading Mishna Dialectically – Discussing with the text

0:00
NaN:NaN:NaN
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds
As a hakdama to Pirkei Avos, this shiur argues that inherited texts like the Mishnah are meant to be talked with dialectically rather than received dogmatically, and that even esoteric readings still treat the text as a fixed authority that never moves. Drawing on Socrates' critique of writing in the *Phaedrus*, the Talmud's way of questioning the Mishnah, and the failure of books to transmit even practical knowledge, it holds that misinterpretation is harmless once a text is engaged as a conversation partner. It traces the dogmatic habit to the modern image of nature as an impersonal authority and Spinoza's call to read Scripture like nature, and suggests that if nature itself is dialectical, even the Torah can be read as a text that answers back.

More episodes from "Iyun Lemachshava English"