
0:00
1:20:32
The women's division took over SmackDown and Raw this week, so Sean and Matt give them the spotlight. The Boys discuss how women dominated recent SmackDown and Raw match cardsThey weigh Crown Jewel’s reported financial stakes against performer safety, citing reports of $60–80 million at risk for Crown Jewel and potentially a quarter-billion dollars if Crown Jewel and WrestleMania were lost.They praise Blake Monroe’s street fight, including character-fitting props such as hairspray and a mirror, and call it a breakout performance.They debate why Cody Rhodes’ presentation feels overly manufactured and whether Randy Orton’s current heel role is convincing.They examine CM Punk’s sit-down segment with Kevin Owens, arguing that Owens controlled the exchange and that Punk’s current character lacks authenticity.They highlight Trick Williams’ fluid performance in a multi-person tag match and discuss his potential move toward the world-title picture.Sean and Matt praise Sami Zayn’s Raw promo for drawing on his Bloodline history, while discussing Jeyvon Evans’ expressive, response and the resulting WWE title match.They credit Triple H with giving talent rest and opportunities, even as they acknowledge that WWE creative can frustrate fans.The hosts announce a planned Veterans Day special episode featuring military stories and experiences. Sean and Matt praise the Lyra Valkyria-Bayley No DQ match, distinguishing its strong feud storytelling from the mechanics of other recent women’s matches.They criticize commentary from Joe Tessitore and Wade Barrett, while crediting Wade with occasionally correcting or clarifying the call.They argue that frequent interference, from Judgment Day, makes matches feel repetitive and robs performers of credibility.They say the Bloodline reunion feels too friendly and ignores prior tensions, while questioning the group’s direction after WarGamesThey joke about the repeated confirmation required to cash in.Sean floats a speculative storyline in which Sami Zayn aligns temporarily with 9-4-6 to weaken Roman Reigns, potentially opening a path for Penta to cash in.They suggest Roman Reigns would benefit from chasing rather than immediately occupying a title picture, and discuss possible future routes involving Oba Femi.They agree Judgment Day needs a meaningful change, with Sean specifically saying Roxanne Perez needs out.They close by promoting their Veterans Day livestream and inviting listeners to follow and share feedback on their podcast platforms.Look for the announced Veterans Day special episode; the hosts say they will share military experiences and provide advance notice of the live time.Chapters00:00 Rocky Horror, music tastes, and the Veterans Day special06:07 Women take over WWE’s weekly match cards06:55 Crown Jewel’s safety concerns and financial stakes12:07 Sami Zayn, Trick Williams, and the women’s storylines17:15 Blake Monroe’s breakout street fight18:06 Why Cody Rhodes’ character feels manufactured22:40 Tag-title changes and Triple H’s approach to talent26:38 Kevin Owens gets the better of CM Punk30:00 Trick Williams shines in the SmackDown main event33:03 Sami Zayn’s Raw promo rewrites his Bloodline story36:22 Jeyvon Evans makes his presence felt38:26 A WWE Championship match is made38:56 Tag-title possibilities for Penta and Je'Von Evans41:16 Lyra Valkyria and Bayley tell a violent No DQ story43:03 Why the commentary team distracted from the matches46:15 The case against constant interference47:45 The Bloodline reunion erases too much history54:44 Big Cass and Ethan Page, then a worked-injury question56:18 Becky Lynch and Liv Morgan deliver a main-event performance01:00:06 Tiffany Stratton’s teased cash-in and the briefcase debate01:05:06 A wild Sami Zayn, 9-4-6, and Penta theory01:09:22 Should Roman Reigns have to chase the title?01:13:23 Why Judgment Day needs a new direction01:15:43 Veterans Day livestream and show sign-off
More episodes from "If We Had The Pencil"



Don't miss an episode of “If We Had The Pencil” and subscribe to it in the GetPodcast app.








