Peter Boghossian - Does Friendship Require Tribal Loyalty?

How do you tell a compelling story about science while staying honest about what we do not know? Science writer Tim Folger joins Jamin Coller to discuss interviewing scientists, translating difficult ideas, and keeping curiosity at the center of the conversation. Tim shares stories from his reporting, including an interview with physicist John Wheeler and his work on tsunamis. We discuss what makes great science writing, the mysteries of quantum mechanics, dark matter and dark energy, the search for life beyond Earth, and the limits of human understanding. The conversation explores both the progress science makes possible and the unanswered questions that keep it interesting. Watch this conversation: YouTube Related conversation: Daniel Whiteson If I'm Really Honest | Become a Superfan #IfImReallyHonest #TeamPossiblyWrong

Can people and societies be good without God? Sociologist Phil Zuckerman joins Jamin Coller to discuss secular life, morality, and what research on highly secular societies can tell us about human well-being. We explore Scandinavia, the relationship between modernization and religion, how belief is passed down through families, and the role of the internet in changing religious communities. Phil also acknowledges areas where religion provides valuable support, including charitable giving, comfort, and community. Jamin and Phil discuss what people can lose when they leave faith and whether secularization is inevitable. Books discussed include Beyond Doubt, Society Without God, What It Means to Be Moral, and Faith No More. Watch this conversation: YouTube Related conversation: Bryan Caplan If I'm Really Honest | Become a Superfan #IfImReallyHonest #TeamPossiblyWrong

What changes when you read the Bible closely as literature? Robert Alter joins Jamin Coller to discuss translating the Hebrew Bible, the artistry of its narratives, contradictions within its books, and what English translations can obscure. We explore word choice, biblical poetry, Ecclesiastes, the two creation accounts, and familiar Psalms that sound different in the original Hebrew. Guest resources: Robert Alter at UC Berkeley | The Hebrew Bible: A Translation with Commentary Watch this conversation: YouTube Related conversation: Kipp Davis If I'm Really Honest | Become a Superfan #IfImReallyHonest #TeamPossiblyWrong

What happens when a minister stops believing, but religion has become his career, community, and identity? Former Pentecostal minister Duane Grady joins Jamin Coller for a conversation about changing beliefs, leaving ministry, and the human cost of being honest about doubt. Duane is president of The Clergy Project, which supports current and former religious professionals who no longer hold supernatural beliefs. Guest resource: The Clergy Project Related conversation: Dan Barker - Trapped as a Pastor More conversations: IfImReallyHonest.com Support the show: Team Possibly Wrong #IfImReallyHonest #TeamPossiblyWrong

Dan Barker is a former evangelical minister, author, musician, and co-president of the Freedom From Religion Foundation. In this conversation, Dan reflects on leaving the ministry, changing deeply held beliefs, building a meaningful life without faith, and defending the separation of church and state. DAN BARKER: Freedom From Religion Foundation: https://ffrf.org/about/ffrf-board/dan-barker/ Books by Dan Barker: https://www.amazon.com/s?k=Dan+Barker+Godless&tag=leapialiv-20 IF I’M REALLY HONEST: Website: https://IfImReallyHonest.com Become a Superfan: https://JaminColler.com/Superfans As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. #IfImReallyHonest #TeamPossiblyWrong #DanBarker #Deconstruction

Dr. Kipp Davis is a biblical scholar specializing in the Dead Sea Scrolls, early Jewish literature, and the history and transmission of biblical texts. In this conversation, we examine what the Dead Sea Scrolls actually tell us, how scholars evaluate ancient manuscripts, and where popular claims about the Bible can outrun the evidence. KIPP DAVIS: Research: https://independent.academia.edu/KippDavis YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@DrKippDavis Books on the Dead Sea Scrolls: https://www.amazon.com/s?k=Kipp+Davis+Dead+Sea+Scrolls&tag=leapialiv-20 IF I’M REALLY HONEST: Website: https://IfImReallyHonest.com Become a Superfan: https://JaminColler.com/Superfans As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. #IfImReallyHonest #TeamPossiblyWrong #KippDavis #DeadSeaScrolls

Will Gervais is a cultural and evolutionary psychologist who studies religious belief, disbelief, morality, and how human minds make sense of gods. In this conversation, we explore why some people believe while others do not, what psychology reveals about atheism and religion, and the assumptions both believers and nonbelievers often get wrong. WILL GERVAIS: Official website: https://willgervais.com/ Research: https://willgervais.com/research-page Disbelief on Amazon: https://www.amazon.com/s?k=Disbelief+Will+Gervais&tag=leapialiv-20 Some links are affiliate links. If you buy through them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. IF I’M REALLY HONEST: Website: https://IfImReallyHonest.com Become a Superfan: https://IfImReallyHonest.com/superfans #IfImReallyHonest #TeamPossiblyWrong #WillGervais

Rolf Potts is a travel writer, essayist, and the bestselling author of Vagabonding and The Vagabond’s Way. In this conversation, we explore what meaningful travel can teach us about attention, freedom, identity, and building a life on purpose. ROLF POTTS: Official website: https://rolfpotts.com/ Books and essays: https://rolfpotts.com/books/ Vagabonding on Amazon: https://www.amazon.com/s?k=Vagabonding+Rolf+Potts&tag=leapialiv-20 IF I’M REALLY HONEST: Website: https://IfImReallyHonest.com Become a Superfan: https://JaminColler.com/Superfans As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. #IfImReallyHonest #TeamPossiblyWrong #RolfPotts #Vagabonding

Peter Boghossian is a philosopher, educator, former Portland State University professor, pioneer of street epistemology, author of A Manual for Creating Atheists, and coauthor of How to Have Impossible Conversations. We discuss intellectual honesty, why changing your mind should be considered a virtue, friendship across ideological lines, the difference between virtue-based relationships and tribal loyalty, and why deliberately choosing difficult things can help us become more substantial human beings. PETER BOGHOSSIAN: Official website: https://peterboghossian.com/ Substack: https://boghossian.substack.com/ YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@drpeterboghossian IF I’M REALLY HONEST: Website: https://IfImReallyHonest.com Become a Superfan: https://JaminColler.com/Superfans #IfImReallyHonest #TeamPossiblyWrong

Bryan Caplan is a New York Times bestselling author, Professor of Economics at George Mason University, Senior Research Fellow at the Mercatus Center, and one of the world's most influential libertarian economists. He's the author of The Myth of the Rational Voter, The Case Against Education, Selfish Reasons to Have More Kids, Open Borders, Build, Baby, Build, and several other bestselling books. His next major work, Unbeatable: The Brutally Honest Case for Free Markets, is scheduled for release in 2027. In this episode, Bryan and I explore one of the questions at the heart of this podcast: how do we know when we're fooling ourselves? We discuss why people often believe things they don't actually act on, whether we're capable of genuine intellectual honesty, why betting can reveal our real beliefs, why comedians sometimes make better truth-tellers than politicians, what caused Bryan to abandon Catholicism and embrace economics, and how social desirability bias shapes everything from religion to politics. We also discuss immigration, education, rationality, self-deception, and what Bryan would change if he could redesign society from scratch. Bryan Caplan Books: https://www.amazon.com/stores/author/B001JSCEV0/allbooks Website: https://www.bcaplan.com/ X: https://x.com/bryan_caplan Become a Superfan: https://JaminColler.com/iirh_Superfans https://IfImReallyHonest.com #IfImReallyHonest #TeamPossiblyWrong