I Love Coaching Podcast | Build an Online Coaching Business: Strategies for Coaches podcast

Your Coaching Identity Is Stuck in Yesterday’s Container

0:00
24:48
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds

You have the career, the credentials, and a long list of results. So why does introducing yourself as a coach still feel like wearing someone else’s cape?

Adam Roach opens with Clark Kent, Bruce Wayne, and Peter Parker (Jess keeps him honest on the Batman one, since her five-year-old is the resident expert) to ask a bigger question: is who you are really who you are? Adam and Jess see it constantly. Professionals who mastered another field arrive in coaching convinced they can only be the container they just left.

Jess brings the story behind the episode. She just came home from her 20-year high school reunion, where she watched who was still wearing the labels from 2006 and who had let them go and chosen a new life. She has changed careers three times, so she knows how different she is from the person people remember. Adam adds the community lens: when imposter syndrome hits, coaches go borrow authority from someone else, and it makes things worse. From there the conversation moves from the big picture to the practical, covering fixed versus growth language, metacognition, and what to do when your own client is stuck.

What you’ll learn

  • Why leaning on a past title or credential feels safe, and what it costs you right now
  • The difference between borrowed authority and your own, and how to tell which one you are using
  • How fixed phrases like “I’m not a tech person” turn into brick walls, and how to reword them
  • Why praising the process instead of the label (“you’re smart”) changes how people respond to hard things
  • How metacognition and the deep dive “why” questions slow down fast-thinking clients without labeling them
  • Why visionaries who want exponential growth can’t get there with linear, fixed thinking
  • Why identity can’t be built in a silo, and what a good reflective community gives you

The big idea

Most of the labels we carry were handed to us before we could choose them, and many coaches keep wearing them because the known feels safer than an unknown future. The way forward is to examine each label, decide on purpose which ones travel with you into tomorrow, and listen to your own language, because fixed phrases are usually where the stuckness lives.

Notable quote

“You lose sight of who you really are because you’re using yesterday’s container as your identity for today.” (Adam Roach)

Resources mentioned

  • Be Your Future Self Now by Benjamin Hardy
  • Mindset by Carol Dweck
  • Coaching offer scorecard: ilovecoachingco.com/scorecard
  • Virtual three-day Sellable Offer Challenge and live workshops: ilovecoachingco.com/events
  • ILC community: ilovecoachingco.com
  • Instagram: @ilovecoachingco / @adamrroach / @thejesswebber
  • YouTube: youtube.com/@ilovecoachingco

Join the community

Ready to build a coaching business you’re proud of? The ILC community is where coaches go to stop guessing and start growing. Start with the scorecard at ilovecoachingco.com/scorecard and see what’s coming at ilovecoachingco.com/events.

More episodes from "I Love Coaching Podcast | Build an Online Coaching Business: Strategies for Coaches"