
0:00
21:48
The 4 box reflective feedback model is a practical alternative to the feedback sandwich that gets employees talking about their own performance first. Leadership trainer Russell Stratton of Bluegem Learning in Calgary, co-author of I Need to F***ing Talk To You, walks through each box, joins Andrea in a live role play, and shares coaching questions managers can use in performance conversations.
Key takeaways:
- The feedback sandwich is so familiar that employees wait for the "but," and the manager does most of the talking.
- The four boxes alternate: the employee says what went well, the manager adds to it, the employee says what they could do even better, and the manager adds anything they missed.
- "What could you do even better?" works for top performers and struggling employees alike.
- Expect the first few conversations to feel awkward. Send questions in advance and give it a few rounds.
- When there is an urgent problem, address it directly. Do not fold it into a feedback model.
- Ask "talk me through what happened" and look at the lead-up to an incident, not only the moment itself.
00:00 Introduction to Russell Stratton
00:57 How this differs from other models
01:01 Problems with the feedback sandwich
02:22 The 4 box reflective model
02:36 Box 1: What went well?
03:57 Box 2: The manager tops up
04:35 Box 3: What could be even better?
05:26 Box 4: The manager adds observations
06:44 When employees don't say anything
08:17 Live role play
11:58 Using the model flexibly
13:31 When the model falls flat
14:48 Urgent problems need a different approach
16:03 Coaching questions for improvement
18:25 Look at what led up to it
20:08 Where to find Russell
21:06 Closing thoughts
**Find Russell**
Website: https://www.bluegemlearning.com/
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/russellstratton/
Book Titles or other links: I Need to F***ing Talk To You: The Art of Navigating Difficult Workplace Conversations (with Ken Cameron): https://www.amazon.ca/Need-ing-Talk-You-Conversations/dp/1777302609
**Find Andrea**
Website: https://thehrhub.ca/
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/andrea-adams1/
More episodes from "The HR Hub"



Don't miss an episode of “The HR Hub” and subscribe to it in the GetPodcast app.








