
16 - Silence is Not Agreement: Why Your Team Needs Disagreement (and how to do it well)
Ever sat in a meeting, heard something you completely disagreed with, and said nothing? Made a face, typed something in the chat and deleted it, or vented to your significant other on the drive home? You're in good company.
This episode is about disagreeing well, which is one of the most underrated professional skills out there. We start with why disagreement is good for teams, including economist Giampaolo Bonomi's "Disagreement Dividend" and the Harvard Business Review's take that research across every social science shows disagreement has real benefits. Then we get into the flip side: groupthink, where harmony (or the appearance of it) takes over for honest deliberation, and what that has cost organizations, including in the lead-up to the 1986 Challenger disaster.
From there, we dig into why good intentions aren't enough, based on a decade of research from Julia Minson (Harvard), Hanne Collins (UCLA), and Michael Yeomans (Imperial College London). Their work points to two gaps that send disagreements sideways: the intention-behavior gap (what we plan to do vs. what we do in the heat of the moment) and the behavior-perception gap (what we do vs. how it's received).
The fix is language you can actually use. Here are the five approaches we cover, with sample phrases for each:
• Indicate that you want to learn. Say out loud that you're curious about the other person's view.
• Acknowledge before you respond. Restate the core of what you heard, without pretending to agree (and without faking it).
• Find your common ground. Name the goal, value, or problem you both care about, so it becomes us-vs-the-problem instead of me-vs-you.
• Hedge your claims. A little intellectual humility makes you more credible, not less.
• Share your story. The experience behind your position can build more trust than another pile of data.
We close with a section for leaders on setting the tone, because how you respond the first time someone pushes back on your idea tells your whole team whether it's safe to be honest with you.
__________
Sources Cited in This Episode
Minson, J.A., Collins, H.K., & Yeomans, M. (2025, November–December). A smarter way to disagree. Harvard Business Review. Reprint R2506J. https://hbr.org/2025/11/a-smarter-way-to-disagree
Bonomi, G. (2024). The disagreement dividend (arXiv:2308.06607v7) [Working paper]. arXiv. https://arxiv.org/abs/2308.06607
Kawamoto, D. (2022, June 1). How to avoid groupthink: 13 tips for the workplace. Built In. https://builtin.com/articles/group-think
Presidential Commission on the Space Shuttle Challenger Accident. (1986, June 6). Report to the President by the Presidential Commission on the Space Shuttle Challenger Accident. NASA. https://www.nasa.gov/history/rogersrep/genindex.htm
Additional Resources Used to Write This Episode
Minson, J. (2025, October 6). A smarter way to disagree. Shorenstein Center on Media, Politics and Public Policy, Harvard Kennedy School. https://shorensteincenter.org/resource/a-smarter-way-to-disagree/
Teitel, A.S. (2018, January 25; updated 2026, January 12). How the Challenger disaster changed NASA. History.com. https://www.history.com/articles/how-the-challenger-disaster-changed-nasa
__________
If the information contained in this episode gave you something to think about, Windrose Coaching and Consulting offers career and leadership skills mentoring and coaching to individuals seeking self-improvement. We also offer consulting services for small and micro businesses. To learn more about how we work, see our Services page.
If you want to support the show directly, you can do that here: https://www.buzzsprout.com/2630991/support. This podcast is a one-woman operation recorded in a bedroom closet with a very inexpensive mic, so any support goes straight toward better gear and more content. Every bit helps, and it's genuinely appreciated.
Not ready to jump into services just yet? Start with our downloadable guide Communicate with Confidence: 8 Tips to Enhance Your Communication Skills and Increase Your Credibility.
AND NOW AVAILABLE!!! The Annual Review Companion 2027
The Annual Review Companion 2027 is your guide to tracking your yearly progress so you can show up to your next annual review with alllllllll the receipts. Get yourself that raise and that promotion you deserve!
Find it in our store: https://glassceilingsmashedpod.myshopify.com/products/2027-annual-review-companion-spiral-bound
Follow us on socials:
Instagram: @windrosecoachingandconsulting
Threads: @windrosecoachingandconsulting
TikTok: @windrose_coaching
For business inquiries: [email protected]
More episodes from "Career Growth Strategies for Women: Glass Ceiling, Smashed"



Don't miss an episode of “Career Growth Strategies for Women: Glass Ceiling, Smashed” and subscribe to it in the GetPodcast app.








