Free Speech Arguments podcast

Can the Government Cap Screen Time for Minors Under the First Amendment? (NetChoice v. Jay Jones)

0:00
53:58
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds

Episode 57: NetChoice v. Jay Jones

NetChoice v. Jay Jones, argued before Judges J. Harvie Wilkinson III, Roger L. Gregory, and DeAndrea Gist Benjamin of the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit on October 28, 2026. Argued by Erin E. Murphy (on behalf of NetChoice) and Tillman J. Breckenridge (on behalf of the Commonwealth of Virginia).  

Case Summary, from the Appellees’ Brief: 

Virginia Senate Bill 854 is one of the latest attempts in a long line of government efforts to restrict new forms of constitutionally protected expression based on concerns about their potential effects on minors. Books, movies, rock music, and video games have all been accused of endangering minors in the past. Today, similar debates rage about “social media.” Those debates are important, and the government may certainly participate in them. But the First Amendment does not take kindly to government efforts to resolve them. The Constitution instead leaves the power to decide what speech and how much of it is appropriate for minors where it belongs: with their parents. 

Nevertheless, several states have recently enacted statutes restricting minors’ access to some of the most popular “social media” services. Courts across the country have held that these laws violate the First Amendment. And rightly so. States may certainly take steps to protect minors who use “social media,” but requiring minors to obtain parental consent before accessing those websites is not a narrowly tailored means of advancing a legitimate governmental interest… 

Like similar state efforts, SB854 violates the First Amendment. The law bans minors from spending more than an hour a day on a covered “social media” website unless they obtain parental consent. SB854, moreover, does not limit its reach to “social media” as that term is commonly understood. It defines “social media” broadly to reach websites like YouTube, blogging platforms like Dreamwidth, and messaging boards like College Confidential. By restricting the ability of minors (and adults, who must now prove their age) to access these websites, Virginia has restricted millions of Virginians “from engaging in the legitimate exercise of First Amendment rights.” 

Issues Presented, from the Opening Brief for Appellant:   

  1. Did the district court err in concluding that NetChoice was likely to establish that Virginia’s Parental Control Provision violates the First Amendment? 
  2. Did the district court err in weighing the public interest, the balance of equities, and irreparable harm against Virginia? 

Resources:   


The Institute for Free Speech promotes and defends the political speech rights to freely speak, assemble, publish, and petition the government guaranteed by the First Amendment. If you’re enjoying the Free Speech Arguments podcast, please subscribe and leave a review on your preferred podcast platform. 

More episodes from "Free Speech Arguments"