Flick Fights! podcast

Toby, Andrew, or Tom? Which Spider-Man had the best debut?

8/10/2026
0:00
2:19:18
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds

It’s a web-slinging war, a spectacular Spider-Man showdown for superhero supremacy!

This week on Flick Fights, three generations of your friendly neighborhood Spider-Man enter the arena as Spider-Man (2002) takes on The Amazing Spider-Man (2012) and Spider-Man: Homecoming (2017)!

Tobey Maguire gave us the earnest, responsibility-burdened Peter Parker who helped launch the modern superhero blockbuster. Andrew Garfield brought attitude, agility, and a Spider-Man who never met a criminal he couldn’t roast. And Tom Holland swung into the MCU as a teenage Peter desperately trying to prove he belonged among Earth’s mightiest heroes.

But nostalgia gets no free passes here.

We break it all down across 10 rounds, including:

🕷️ The Peter Parker Test
🕷️ Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man
🕷️ With Great Power...
🕷️ The Villain
🕷️ Web-Slinging & Action
🕷️ The Spider-Man Moment

Three Peters. Three Spider-Men. Three very different visions of what makes the character great.

When the webs clear and only one Spider-Man is left standing... who truly deserves to wear the mask?

00:00 Intro

03:07 Tale of the Tape

09:45 Spider-Man (2002)

48:41 TASM

01:13:56 Homecoming

01:39:29 Round 1

01:43:17 Round 2

01:46:10 Round 3

01:49:12 Round 4

01:51:26 Round 5

01:54:33 Round 6

01:57:39 Round 7

02:00:35 Round 8

02:02:56 Round 9

02:05:19 Round 10

02:07:35 Trivia Facts

02:15:18 Next Week

More episodes from "Flick Fights!"