Flavorphiles podcast

Halloween Isn’t What It Used to Be

10/31/2026
0:00
40:19
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds
It’s actually Halloween, and Tanner and Jerry Agar are in full costume (Frankenstein and Little Bo Peep, for those listening on the radio) to dig into how Halloween, and its candy, went from homemade to store-bought.

Tanner opens with the Stone Fence, an 1862 Jerry Thomas cocktail of rye, hard apple cider and bitters. Then we trace trick-or-treating from Celtic roots to popcorn balls to the 1954 Milky Way ad that made Halloween a candy holiday, and where the poisoned-candy panic really came from.

Does candy taste worse than when you were a kid? Tanner gives four reasons it might: changing recipes, shrinking sizes, your own taste buds, and nostalgia. Plus the Canadian origin of Sour Patch Kids and the science of why sour candy hurts so good.

To close, Tanner takes on the candies still made exactly like they used to be, from candy corn to circus peanuts, and how a chef would save them. (Mostly by melting them down. Except one: the wax bottles, which are beyond saving.)

 Happy Halloween. Don’t be the house that gives out raisins.

Chapters:
00:00 Happy Halloween from Flavorphiles
00:52 Amuse booze: the Stone Fence
02:00 Where trick-or-treating came from
03:23 Popcorn balls and homemade treats
04:07 The 1954 ad that made Halloween a candy holiday
06:12 The poisoned candy panic
08:24 How much candy is in that bucket?
10:37 Does candy taste worse than it used to?
12:11 Reason 1: Recipes change
14:50 Reason 2: Shrinkflation and shapes
17:23 Reason 3: Your taste buds grew up
19:05 Reason 4: Nostalgia
22:00 Why sour candy hurts so good
28:23 Making sour candy at home
31:48 Candies that need to change (and how to save them)
40:58 The one candy that can’t be saved

Thank you for listening! Join us again every weekend for more food inspired fun. Have questions you want answered, comments to make the show better, do you want to join our growing list of radio stations partners, or just keep in touch? Let us know at Flavorphiles.com. 

Follow on Instagram:
Flavorphiles: https://www.instagram.com/flavorphilespod/
Tanner: https://www.instagram.com/tagaragar/

Follow on Tik Tok:
https://www.tiktok.com/@flavorphiles

All episodes produced and owned by Tanner Agar. All rights reserved.

More episodes from "Flavorphiles"