Filmsuck podcast

Giving LIZZIE BORDEN 40 Whacks

11/7/2026
0:00
1:05:21
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds

Even knowing that writer-director-producer Ryan Murphy routinely chooses fascinating television series topics based on historical figures and then makes infuriatingly stupid shows about them, co-hosts Eileen and Dolores were unprepared for the big bloody mess that is MONSTER: THE LIZZIE BORDEN STORY. The biggest problem is that it’s not actually the Lizzie Borden story, if you know anything about the notorious ax-murderer, acquitted in 1893 of killing her rich miserly father and hated stepmother, but assumed to be guilty by almost everybody down through the generations. It’s also not the Aileen Wuornos story or the Countess Elizabeth Bathory story, though those women—convicted of multiple murders in very different centuries, countries, classes, and life circumstances of every kind—are also dragged in to further confuse the addled narrative. It’s a kind of pseudo-feminist TV jamboree positing that all women who kill are oppressed by the patriarchy in the same way and are therefore, essentially, one Universal Woman Killer.

More episodes from "Filmsuck"