REVIEW: NORTH BY NORTHWEST
Review of North by NorthwestNotable Quotables: Sherry introduces a segment featuring quotes directly from Alfred Hitchcock. These include his beliefs that a film's length should match the endurance of the human bladder, that blondes act like "virgin snow" for showing bloody footprints, and that directors should make the audience suffer as much as possible.The Root of Suspense: The hosts discuss how Hitchcock's self-admitted cowardice and low threshold for fear helped him craft compelling suspense. They compare this to author Stephen King, noting that King wrote Pet Sematary based on his real-life fear of his children getting hit by a vehicle near their home, and that the resulting story terrified King so much he initially hid it in a drawer.Critical Reception: North by Northwest boasts a 97% critic score and a 94% fan score on Rotten Tomatoes. This makes it only the second movie the podcast has covered to rate this highly, placing it alongside Aliens.Production & Box Office: Hitchcock had already completed 45 feature films before making this movie. In 1959, it had an estimated budget between $4 million and $4.3 million. It was a financial hit, grossing $13 million worldwide at the time. Adjusted for inflation, the modern equivalent would be a $49 million budget with a $162 million gross. Following this project, Hitchcock immediately went on to film Psycho, releasing it in 1960.Ratings and Reception: The audio file "one for summary.mp3" highlights that North by Northwest holds a 97% critic score and a 94% fan score. This places it alongside Aliens as one of the highest-rated films discussed on the podcast. Theatrical Economics: In 1959, the film carried an estimated budget of $4 million to $4.3 million. It achieved a worldwide gross of $13 million. Adjusted for modern inflation, this translates to a $49 million budget and a $162 million box office return. Theatrical profits during this era were heavily dependent on popcorn and concession stand sales to offset the rising threat of television. Protagonist Profile: Cary Grant stars as Roger Thornhill, a slick, multi-divorced advertising executive who relies on "expedient exaggeration". He is portrayed as a superficial character who regularly bribes his overbearing mother. The central conflict begins when Thornhill is mistaken for a spy named George Kaplan and is subsequently kidnapped. Production Delays and Hitchcock's Structure: The film's production ran seven weeks behind schedule. Because Hitchcock delayed the start of filming to avoid a confrontation, Cary Grant earned an extra $5,000 per day through a contractual penalty clause. Instead of a traditional narrative, the film is deliberately structured as a series of isolated vignettes meant to foster confusion. The plot was intentionally disjointed to the point that Grant openly complained on set about not understanding the story. Directors Guild Trivia: The hosts discuss the history of "Allen Smithee," a pseudonym established by the Directors Guild of America in 1968. This alias was utilized by directors who wanted to legally remove their names from a troubled film. The guild eventually retired the pseudonym around the year 2000 after it became too widely recognized by the general public. In this segment of "two for summary.mp3," the hosts shift their focus to discussing the structure and plot beats of North by Northwest. They explore how Hitchcock constructed the film intentionally, not necessarily tracking traditional narrative beats, but rather a sequence of events designed to build confusion. Opening and Characterization: The hosts agree on the film's "Opening Image," introducing Cary Grant's character, Roger Thornhill, as a slick, fast-talking, superficial advertising executive whose life is defined by manipulation and dodging responsibility. The Catalyst and Debate: The "Catalyst" occurs when Thornhill is kidnapped by two men who mistakenly identify him as a spy named George Kaplan. This leads to the "Debate" section, which involves Thornhill being interrogated by the antagonist, Philip Vandamm, played by James Mason. Vandamm forces Thornhill to drink a large amount of bourbon and then stages a drunk driving accident. Thornhill survives but faces a crisis, unable to convince the police, a judge, or his mother of the kidnapping, forcing him to investigate George Kaplan himself. The B Story and Conflict: The "B Story" introduces Eve Kendall, played by Eva Marie Saint. A key point of contention for the hosts is a scene where Thornhill attempts to get Kendall's attention by causing a commotion at an auction, hoping to be arrested so he can speak with the police. However, he is thwarted when the police turn out to be agents working for "The Professor," a high-ranking intelligence officer who reveals that Kendall is actually a double agent working against Vandamm. Midpoint Disagreement: The hosts debate what constitutes the "Midpoint" of the film. Some argue it's the iconic crop duster scene, while another suggests it's when Thornhill enters George Kaplan's hotel room and assumes Kaplan's identity. They also debate the "False Defeat" and "False Victory," unable to reach a consensus due to the film's non-traditional structure. The Midpoint Cont.: Following Roger Thornhill's staged drunk driving accident, the hosts pinpoint the film's "False Defeat." This occurs when Thornhill fails to convince authorities or his mother of his kidnapping, forcing him to track down George Kaplan himself. The group disagrees on the exact "Midpoint," with AI picking the iconic crop-duster attack while one host favors Thornhill entering Kaplan's hotel room. This discrepancy, the hosts conclude, is typical of Hitchcock's preference for disjointed vignettes over a standard three-act structure. A "False Victory" at the Auction: The hosts classify the auction scene as the film's "False Victory". To escape Van Damm's henchmen, Thornhill acts erratically at an auction to get arrested. He considers this a success until he realizes the arresting officers are intelligence agents, and he's taken to "The Professor," a spymaster who reveals the truth about Eve Kendall. The "All is Lost" Moment: The "All is Lost" beat happens late in the film. Thornhill agrees to a fake shooting to restore Kendall's cover, which works initially. However, the plan unravels when he discovers Van Damm intends to leave the country with Kendall that night, effectively removing her from the spy operation. The Climax at Mount Rushmore: The film's climax is the famous chase across the faces of Mount Rushmore. Thornhill discovers that Van Damm's henchman, Leonard, knows the shooting was fake and plans to expose Kendall. The struggle on the monument ends with Thornhill managing to pull Kendall up from the edge of the cliff, a shot that immediately transitions into the film's final image. The "Train Into the Tunnel" and Reviews: The hosts discuss the famous "Final Image"—the very suggestive shot of a train entering a tunnel, symbolizing Thornhill and Kendall consummating their marriage. The hosts note that such an overt double-entendre was unusual and rebellious for the era. Ultimately, three of the four hosts recommend the movie, praising Cary Grant's performance and Hitchcock's masterful, if uniquely structured, suspense.