Executives Unplugged podcast

The Truth About Hiring Your First Head of Product

0:00
27:34
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds

Three top executive recruiters and Foursquare founder Dennis Crowley reveal why the candidate with the perfect resume is usually the wrong hire — and how to find the right one.

Most CEO-CPO relationships fail within the first 18 months and a lot of that pain starts with how the hire was made in the first place.

In this episode, I sat down with three of the best executive recruiters in the business — Chris Running, Jodi Jefferson, and Michael Cullen — plus Dennis Crowley, founder of Foursquare and Hopscotch Labs, to unpack the biggest mistakes founders and CEOs make when hiring their first VP of Product or CPO at Series A through Series C companies.

We cover: why many searches derail, the logo trap that seduces hiring managers into picking the wrong candidate, why you should look for trajectory over altitude, the management answer that's a complete red flag, how AI fluency is reshaping what "great" looks like in a product leader, and what it actually takes to close top talent in a market that's shifting fast.

Whether you're a founder about to make this hire or a product leader evaluating your next opportunity, this episode gives you the playbook from both sides of the table.

Chapters

01:13 Start With Why

03:10 Avoid Logo Trap

04:28 Real Search Example

07:50 Trajectory Not Altitude

08:48 Assess Judgment & Speed

10:52 Culture Fit Walkthrough

12:28 Management In Details

13:59 AI Native Leaders

17:15 Hiring With Conviction

19:23 Candidate Due Diligence

20:48 Align Expectations

23:19 Close The Candidate

25:13 The Market Shift

26:14 Five Takeaways

Find the guests on LinkedIn:

Jodi Jefferson: https://www.linkedin.com/in/jodijefferson/

Michael Cullen: https://www.linkedin.com/in/cullenmm/

Chris Running: https://www.linkedin.com/in/chris-running-a94a8025/

Dennis Crowley: https://www.linkedin.com/in/dpstyles/

More episodes from "Executives Unplugged"