
🌿 Beyond the Hierarchy: Rethinking Evidence in Occupational Therapy
When I first learned about evidence-based practice, I remember staring at that glossy triangle, the research hierarchy pyramid, with meta-analyses gleaming at the top like sacred scripture.
It was comforting at first. Finally, a clear map of what counts as truth. But once I entered practice, that tidy hierarchy started to crumble under the weight of real people’s lives. I kept running into questions that the research at the top of the pyramid could only partly answer.
The Trouble with the Old Pyramid
The traditional evidence pyramid is familiar from evidence-based medicine. It gives us a place to start when we want to know whether a treatment caused a measurable change, like whether a medication lowers blood pressure (Duke University Medical Center Library, n.d.).
In OT, we’re often asking what it takes for someone to do something that matters to them, in the place where they actually do it. The activity, the environment, and the person’s own reasons for doing it all shape what happens. I see this in home health, where I’m often working with one person at a time, in the middle of a life already in progress. That context can change how I use a study’s findings and what I look for next.
The Tomlin & Borgetto Research Pyramid
In 2011, George Tomlin and Bernhard Borgetto published Research Pyramid: A New Evidence-Based Practice Model for Occupational Therapy in the American Journal of Occupational Therapy. Their model puts descriptive research at the base, with experimental, outcome, and qualitative research forming the three sides.
* Descriptive research helps us observe and describe what people do and the conditions in which they do it.
* Experimental research helps us ask whether an intervention caused a change.
* Outcome research helps us see what changes when an intervention is used in practice.
* Qualitative research helps us understand people’s experiences and what those experiences mean to them.
I appreciate that the model still asks us to look closely at how well a study was done. It also asks us to think about what kind of research can answer the question we’re bringing to it. Sometimes I need evidence from more than one side of the pyramid to make sense of what I’m seeing.
Why This Matters in Practice
An RCT can help me decide which exercise might improve shoulder flexion. In home health, I also want to know whether that change helps someone garden with her grandchildren or return to painting without pain. Sometimes improving shoulder mobility makes a real difference. Sometimes we also need to change where the supplies are stored or how long someone can comfortably work at the easel.
Occupational therapy lives where biology meets biography. That’s one reason occupational science literacy matters to me. If I hear “I want to get back to gardening,” I might picture weeding or carrying a watering can. My client might be thinking about teaching her grandchildren how to grow tomatoes. Understanding what she wants to return to changes what I pay attention to and what we count as progress.
Reclaiming Evidence as a Living Practice
Whiteford and Wright-St Clair’s work on occupation in context gives me another way to think about this. If we only measure what’s easiest to standardize, we may miss what people value about a program or how they make it work in their own lives.
I think about this with community programs, arts-based approaches, and culturally grounded practices. I want to know what changes for participants, how they describe that change, and what it takes to make the program work in a particular community. Those are all questions we can investigate, and they call for different kinds of research.
Continue the Conversation in the Evolved Living Collaborative
I started the Evolved Living Collaborative because I wanted a place where we could read and talk about occupational science together and connect it to what we’re seeing in practice. It’s free to join, and OTs, OTAs, students, educators, and curious colleagues from other disciplines are welcome.
I’d love to hear from you. When has a client’s story changed what you counted as a meaningful outcome?
Join the Evolved Living Collaborative on Skool
References
Duke University Medical Center Library. (n.d.). The evidence-based practice pyramid. Duke University Medical Center Library
Tomlin, G., & Borgetto, B. (2011). Research pyramid: A new evidence-based practice model for occupational therapy. American Journal of Occupational Therapy, 65(2), 189–196. https://doi.org/10.5014/ajot.2011.000828
Whiteford, G., & Wright-St Clair, V. (2004). Occupation and practice in context. Churchill Livingstone.
Get full access to Dr. Josie Jarvis OT at josiejarvisot.substack.com/subscribe
More episodes from "Evolved Living Podcast"



Don't miss an episode of “Evolved Living Podcast” and subscribe to it in the GetPodcast app.








