Defying Gentrification podcast

Yes, there are ways that DC defies gentrification

0:00
18:11
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds

Welcome back to my series where I grade the cities I’ve lived in on whether they are defying gentrification. We are tackling one of the poster children of American gentrification, Washington, DC, with my new rubric. You can listen above or read more below.

How Do I See Gentrification Affecting DC?

So much has been written about how gentrification has affected DC. I want to honor all of that writing and scholarship, and continue to sharpen my own writings and analysis about such topics, like this article I wrote for Greater Greater Washington almost a decade ago, upon the release of Derek Hyra’s book Race, Class, and Politics in the Cappuccino City

Much of that prior scholarship uses the looser definition of poor people being replaced by rich people, which allows for Black wealthy people to replace white poor people, which is outlined in this Capital B Atlanta article that I analyzed a few weeks ago. DC has been run by a Black mayor since the 1970s. Beloved “mayor-for-life” Marion Berry has stated that he didn’t intend for improvements that he made to the city, some of which could be construed as gentrification, to actually be gentrification.

However, he and others didn’t anticipate how mass Black job loss, underpayment, and undervaluing of properties that cause many forms of Black wealth to be taxed, directly by the government and indirectly by other forces of society, would affect our ability to thrive past the Civil Rights Movement and into the late 20th and early 21st century.

In addition, blame for gentrification in DC has also been lazily applied to certain infrastructure improvements that don’t cause gentrification elsewhere, i.e., the bike lane, which in Greensboro, my hometown, has existed in Black and poor neighborhoods for years, and those communities have not seen dramatic change.

That being said, my rubric puts numbers on my feelings and how people feel about neighborhood change. The concept of defying gentrification already alludes to Black people being able to thrive even though they pay more in rent. It asks us to examine if Black students are doing well in their schools amidst all these changes. It asks us if Black business exists as an ecosystem of commerce, not a token of capitalism.

Yes, without apology, this rubric grades how well Black folks can thrive in the regions I’ve spent time on the ground. And with Black folks being the most marginalized in large metro regions, as shown in study after study, this is how I landed where I landed.

Grab your favorite beverage as I outline how I graded DC, and pop over to the full rubric to understand how I graded DC. (Scroll down to the PS section on that post to get back here)

First of all, my number twos, the things we are doing great at:

* Spiritual spaces of all faiths that affirm and delight in Black, disabled, feminist, and/or queer lives

* Comprehensive public transit exists for more than just paratransit users

* Bookstores and Libraries that affirm all authors and all readers

* Parks, playgrounds, waterfronts, and other natural resources/outdoor activities not closed off to the public

* Black, LGBTQ, disabled, and feminist community centers and events

* A way to get out of town that’s not your personal vehicle (if you even have one).

* Art and creative spaces for all skill and desire levels

* Culturally competent non-medical hair and body care

That’s a lot of things. And it only scratches the surface of how these spaces and amenities make gentrification less of a downer. However, we do have to talk about what got ones and .05s and why those things can negate everything above.

What got a one?

* Thriving entrepreneurship and gainful employment are available to more than white, straight, able-bodied, wealthy people.

* Wraparound medical care

* Food that provides both joy and basic nutritional needs in all neighborhoods

* Schools that affirm Black children K-12, no matter their ability level or perceived behavior

Everything that is a two, starts to care less if you’re hungry, sick, broke, and your kids are being mistreated.

In DC, only some neighborhoods have these vital things. Only some neighborhoods have some of the 2s as well, but those 2s are nice-to-haves; these 1s are vitals. And now to the thing we all need: shelter.

DC scored a 0.5, like all cities, on its housing measure. While there are efforts to support homeownership, to support renters who fall behind on rent, and to rapidly re-house families, these programs have all seen budget failures over the last 2-4 years, during a time when shelter saved lives above and beyond what’s normally needed, due to the global COVID-19 pandemic.

If these avenues had worked, I’d be writing this post from DC, instead of Baltimore.

This is why this rubric is still very personal and very biased. However, every researcher brings a bias to the table. The way we get away from that bias is by inviting you, the public, to share your thoughts and to take our surveys for yourself. You can do that for DC by pressing the button below. You can also comment and let me know what you want added to the rubric.

https://form.jotform.com/262383869171063

And you can come by next week to see how I graded Baltimore and how I see Baltimore’s gentrification showing up!

Until next time,

Kristen

PS: Come journal with us if gentrification and related land/propery based trauma has you down this coming Thursday from 8-10 pm Eastern. RSVP here.

PPS: I have a number of books on DC’s gentrification in my Bookshop.org store. Support me as you build up your knowledge of gentrification in DC.



Get full access to Defying Gentrification with Kristen Jeffers at theblackurbanist.substack.com/subscribe

More episodes from "Defying Gentrification"