
Alice Fontier grew up in a small upstate New York town near the Pennsylvania border, where her family was the only non-white family in the school district. In this conversation with her friend and fellow New York defense lawyer Lindsay Lewis, she describes being arrested at 16 after a prank phone call, a case that ended in an adjournment in contemplation of dismissal, and the three years of police visits to her home that followed. She says the experience showed her that policing follows what the police care about and who they care about, not what is true.
Alice traces her career from there. After graduating from law school in 2003, she joined the Federal Defenders in San Diego, where she tried 19 felony jury trials in two years and argued three cases before the Ninth Circuit. She returned to New York and joined the Bronx Defenders in 2005, where arraignment shifts meant 20 to 25 cases, broken windows policing, and bail that could be set on any charge. She describes standing next to clients who pleaded guilty to get out of jail, the day she held 133 active cases, and the thought that she was becoming a worse lawyer. She explains how that period shapes the way she mentors lawyers and the policy and legislative work she does, including bail reform in New York, and she walks through what happens to a person's job, home, and family when bail is set and a trial is two or three years away.
Alice and Lindsay also discuss Alice's years in private practice alongside Josh Dratel, where she kept a caseload of assigned 18B and CJA cases, and what it is like to work in the courtroom as a woman and a woman of color. Alice talks about how she dresses for court, being mistaken for an interpreter or an intern, getting into Rikers Island without ID, and how she approaches cross-examining a young complainant. They discuss the so-called cannibal cop case, the questions she received from the public as a woman defending it, and why she and her co-counsel sat close to their client in front of the jury. Alice describes how becoming a mother changed the way she thinks about the families in her cases. She closes with her advice for new public defenders, that the work is not for everyone and that leaving it is not a failure, and with what she tells women who are considering criminal defense.
More episodes from "Defend(H)ers"



Don't miss an episode of “Defend(H)ers” and subscribe to it in the GetPodcast app.




