
“I Don’t Know, Great Question”: Letting Students Watch Experts Think with Marty Samuels
Faculty build their careers exploring new questions in their field, so why do we sometimes feel pressure to hide that process from our students? In this episode, Amanda Irvin talks with Marty Samuels, Director of Faculty Programs and Services at Columbia’s CTL, about the myth of the all-knowing instructor and what it costs students when they see only the polished results of expert thinking.
Samuels explains why inviting students into the “crunchy,” unresolved questions of a discipline matters: it builds their confidence and curiosity, strengthens their sense of belonging, and shows them how their own contributions can move the field forward. He recalls a “blue sky” assignment from a Life Sciences 1a course at Harvard University, where first-year students took a problem they cared about and developed it across the semester. Samuels also shares ways to give students a say in their learning, from project formats to course policies, and closes with one small experiment to try in your very next class.
Recommended Readings / References:
Irvin, A. (Host). (2026, March 26). Bonus episode: Reimagining teaching and learning in the age of AI. A conversation with Columbia University students (Season 11, Episode 5) [Audio podcast episode]. In Dead ideas in teaching and learning. Columbia University Center for Teaching and Learning. https://open.spotify.com/episode/6xZnvizo2Y2dh5F0VqSlED
Wasik, B. (2026, October 5). 100 unanswered questions about ourselves, our world and our universe. The New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2026/10/05/science/100-unanswered-questions-science.html
Cullen, S., & Oppenheimer, D. (2024). Choosing to learn: The importance of student autonomy in higher education. Science Advances, 10(29), Article eado6759. https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.ado6759
More episodes from "Dead Ideas in Teaching and Learning"



Don't miss an episode of “Dead Ideas in Teaching and Learning” and subscribe to it in the GetPodcast app.








