Cortisol Coach podcast

Menopause Weight Gain After 50: Why what worked in Your 40s Stops Working with Natalie Jill

11/13/2026
0:00
22:33
Rewind 15 seconds
Fast Forward 15 seconds

Menopause Weight Gain After 50: Why What Worked in Your 40s Stops Working with Natalie Jill

Apply to be a guest on the Cortisol Coach Podcast:

https://podcast.itschristinemarie.com

Find Christine’s Favorite Supplements:

https://itschristinemarie.com

You are doing the same workouts, eating the same way, and holding the same mindset that has always worked for you, but your body is responding like a stranger. The weight keeps creeping up, your energy is not what it used to be, and everyone keeps telling you it is just hormones or just getting older. And somewhere along the way, you’ve started wondering if this is simply what life after 40 is supposed to look like.

What if there isn’t just one thing going on? What if your hormones, thyroid, gut health, cortisol, and overall toxic load are all part of the same bigger picture? This episode is going to challenge the way you think about menopause weight gain and what your body may actually be asking for.

In this episode of the Cortisol Coach Podcast, Christine Marie sits down with Natalie Jill, the Midlife Health Detective and Fat Loss Expert, creator of Total Body Thrive and The 7 Day Jump Start, host of the top rated podcast Midlife Conversations, and bestselling author with a community of more than 3 million followers. Natalie has helped more than 250,000 women transform their health, and she is known for turning complicated topics into honest girlfriend to girlfriend conversations.

Natalie is a licensed master’s sports nutritionist and fat loss expert who spent her entire 40s believing nothing really changes as you age. She thought she had it all figured out. Then 50 hit. She started getting injured again and again, gained 20 pounds without changing a single thing, and learned her blood sugar was climbing. She did what so many of us do. She tightened up her diet, worked out harder, and added hormone therapy, and still nothing moved.

That is when she stopped guessing and started doing detective work.

What makes this conversation so powerful is that Natalie doesn’t hand you one magic fix. She walks through the three phase order of operations she now uses with the women she coaches. First you upgrade your belief set. Then you uncomplicate your nutrition. Then you do the detective work one area at a time, looking at things like thyroid, gut health, cortisol, and toxic load. She also explains what she calls one thing itis, the habit so many of us have of believing a single fix is going to solve everything.

And this is where the conversation gets personal. Christine first saw Natalie speak in person at Dr. Anna’s event and has wanted her on the show ever since. She shares that she did extensive testing before starting hormone therapy about four months ago, and the two of them talk about why hormone therapy can be a helpful tool but is rarely the whole answer.

Natalie also gives you three simple words you can use today when you feel overwhelmed and stuck: decide, vision, and action. And yes, she has a very clear answer on cardio versus lifting, and why walking still counts.

Today, Natalie says she is the healthiest, strongest, and fittest she has ever been at 55, and she is the first to tell you she is still peeling back layers. Her story is a reminder that when your body stops responding the way it used to, it doesn’t mean you are broken. It may simply mean there is more to uncover.

Whether you are navigating menopause weight gain, brain fog, inflammation, stubborn blood sugar, or the frustration of doing all the right things and not getting the results you used to, this conversation will give you a different perspective on what your body might need next.

In this episode you will hear:

Why what worked in your 40s may stop working after 50

How Natalie went from believing nothing changes with age to gaining weight, getting injured, and facing rising blood sugar

Why menopause weight gain, brain fog, and low energy are rarely about just one thing

What Natalie’s upgrade, uncomplicate, and detective work order of operations looks like

How thyroid health, gut health, cortisol, and toxic load can all play a part in stubborn weight and inflammation

Why Natalie asks what is feeding the problem instead of chasing one single number

What one thing itis is and why so many women get stuck in it

Why hormone therapy is one tool in the toolbox and not the whole answer

How Christine approached testing before starting hormone therapy

How decide, vision, and action can change the way you show up for your health

Why lifting for muscle matters so much for longevity and why walking still counts

Connect with Natalie Jill:

Website: https://www.nataliejill.com

Total Body Thrive: https://totalbodythrive.com

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/nataliejillfit

Podcast: Midlife Conversations (search it on Apple Podcasts or Spotify)

Connect with Christine:

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/cortisol_coach

To be a guest on the Cortisol Coach Podcast: https://podcast.itschristinemarie.com

Find Christine’s Favorite Supplements: https://itschristinemarie.com

If this episode blessed you:

Leave a review on Apple Podcasts. It takes 60 seconds and helps other women discover the Cortisol Coach Podcast.

Follow the Cortisol Coach Podcast so you never miss an episode.

Share this episode with one woman who is doing all the right things and needs encouragement to keep looking for answers.

SEO Keywords and Tags:

menopause weight gain, menopause weight gain after 50, perimenopause weight gain, weight loss after 50, weight gain after 40, why weight loss stops working, midlife weight loss, fat loss after 50, fat loss after 40, hormones and inflammation, inflammation and weight gain, thyroid and weight gain, gut health and hormones, gut health and weight loss, cortisol and weight gain, toxic load and weight gain, hormone replacement therapy women, HRT and weight loss, progesterone and sleep, blood sugar and menopause, prediabetes women over 40, brain fog menopause, midlife health, women over 40 health, lifting weights menopause, strength training for women over 50, longevity women over 40, Natalie Jill, Midlife Conversations, Total Body Thrive, The 7 Day Jump Start, midlife health detective, cortisol coach podcast, Christine Marie podcast, Cortisol Coach Christine Marie

This episode shares Natalie’s personal experiences and educational perspectives. Natalie is not a medical doctor, and this conversation is not a substitute for individualized medical advice or a recommendation to change any prescribed treatment.

More episodes from "Cortisol Coach"